Department of Psychology, Dalhousie University Halifax, NS, Canada.
Front Aging Neurosci. 2011 Nov 15;3:17. doi: 10.3389/fnagi.2011.00017. eCollection 2011.
Ishigami and Klein (2010) showed that scores of the three attention networks (alerting, orienting, and executive control) measured with the two versions of the Attention Network Test (ANT; Fan et al., 2002; Callejas et al., 2005) were robust over 10 sessions of repeated testing even though practice effects were consistently observed especially in the executive network when young adults were tested. The current study replicated their method to examine robustness, stability, reliability, and isolability of the networks scores when older adults were tested with these ANTs. Ten test sessions, each containing two versions of the ANT, were administered to 10 older adults. Participants were asked to indicate the direction of a target arrow, flanked by distractors, presented either above or below the fixation following auditory signals or/and visual cue. Network scores were calculated using orthogonal subtractions of performance in selected conditions. All network scores remained highly significant even after nine previous sessions despite some practice effects in the executive and the alerting networks. Some lack of independence among the networks was found. The relatively poor reliability of network scores with one session of data rises to respectable levels as more data is added.
Ishigami 和 Klein(2010)的研究表明,即使在年轻人接受测试时,练习效应始终存在,尤其是在执行网络中,使用两种版本的注意力网络测试(ANT;Fan 等人,2002;Callejas 等人,2005)测量的三个注意力网络(警觉、定向和执行控制)的分数在 10 次重复测试中仍然非常稳健。本研究复制了他们的方法,当老年人使用这些 ANTs 进行测试时,检验了网络分数的稳健性、稳定性、可靠性和可分离性。10 次测试,每次包含两种版本的 ANT,都被分配给 10 名老年人。参与者被要求根据听觉信号或/和视觉提示,指示在固定点上方或下方呈现的、被分心物包围的目标箭头的方向。使用在选定条件下的性能的正交减法计算网络分数。尽管在执行和警觉网络中存在一些练习效应,但所有网络分数仍然高度显著,即使在之前的九次测试之后也是如此。发现网络之间存在一定程度的缺乏独立性。随着数据的增加,网络分数的可靠性相对较差,一次测试的数据上升到可接受的水平。