Division of Medical Physics, Department of Diagnostic Radiology, University Hospital Schleswig-Holstein, Campus Kiel, Kiel, Germany.
J Bone Miner Metab. 2012 May;30(3):373-80. doi: 10.1007/s00774-011-0335-z. Epub 2011 Dec 2.
The intracardiac injection model is a commonly used in vivo model to test therapeutic response in bone metastases. However, few studies have critically compared the performance of different imaging methods in terms of sensitivity and quantitative assessment of osteolytic lesions. We performed in vivo optical and plain radiographic imaging of bone metastases followed by high-sensitivity ex vivo micro-computed tomography (micro-CT) imaging. This approach allowed for quantitative assessment of in vivo imaging techniques using fluorescence and plain radiography. Comparison of lesions detected in vivo by fluorescent optical imaging with ex vivo micro-CT revealed that the limited spatial resolution of fluorescent optical imaging may underestimate the number of bone metastases. Radiography was compared with micro-CT for the detection of osteolytic lesions. When using dichotomous yes/no grading, there was a 64% agreement in detection of osteolytic lesions. When subjective semiquantitative grading methods were used to assess the extent of osteolytic lesions, a positive association between the micro-CT grades and the square root of the radiography-based grades was observed (p < 0.05). Micro-CT also showed a significant association with fluorescent optical values; however, no such association was observed between lesion scores based on radiographs and those based on fluorescent imaging. The findings reveal an approximate two-fold sensitivity for micro-CT compared to plain radiography in the detection of osteolytic lesions. Significant associations between micro-CT-based osteolytic lesion grade and tumor growth characterized by increased fluorescent area document the value of these two techniques for the assessment of osteolytic bone metastases.
心内注射模型是一种常用于测试骨转移治疗反应的体内模型。然而,很少有研究从敏感性和溶骨性病变的定量评估方面来批判性地比较不同成像方法的性能。我们对骨转移进行了体内光学和普通放射成像,然后进行了高灵敏度的离体微计算机断层扫描(micro-CT)成像。这种方法允许使用荧光和普通放射摄影术对体内成像技术进行定量评估。将荧光光学成像在体内检测到的病变与离体 micro-CT 进行比较表明,荧光光学成像的空间分辨率有限,可能会低估骨转移的数量。比较放射摄影术与 micro-CT 对溶骨性病变的检测。使用二分 yes/no 分级时,在检测溶骨性病变方面有 64%的一致性。当使用主观半定量分级方法来评估溶骨性病变的程度时,观察到 micro-CT 分级与基于放射学的分级的平方根之间存在正相关(p < 0.05)。micro-CT 还与荧光光学值有显著关联;然而,基于放射摄影术的病变评分与基于荧光成像的病变评分之间没有观察到这种关联。研究结果显示,micro-CT 在检测溶骨性病变方面的敏感性比普通放射摄影术高约两倍。基于 micro-CT 的溶骨性病变分级与以荧光区域增加为特征的肿瘤生长之间的显著关联证明了这两种技术在评估溶骨性骨转移中的价值。