Rizzo Renata, Gulisano Mariangela, Calì Paola Valeria, Curatolo Paolo
Section of Child Neuropsychiatry, Maternal-Infantile and Radiological Sciences Department, Catania University, Via Santa Sofia 78, 95123 Catania, Italy.
Brain Dev. 2012 Sep;34(8):667-73. doi: 10.1016/j.braindev.2011.11.006. Epub 2011 Dec 16.
Recent studies using cluster analysis and factor analysis have suggested that Tourette Syndrome (TS) should no longer be considered a unitary condition.
We retrospectively studied the long term clinical course of 100 TS patients. The patients were assessed at the onset and after 10 years follow-up to evaluate the severity of tic, the Obsessive Compulsive Disorder (OCD), the Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD) and the presence of anxiety and depression, rage attacks, self injuries behavior. Moreover at the follow-up they completed an evaluation scale on quality of life to assess the impairment in everyday life after 10 years of illness.
The "pure TS" clinical group (38 subjects) showed after 10 years follow-up that 58% carried on with the same clinical phenotype, whereas 42% changed in "TS+OCD" phenotype. Fifty-five percentage required pharmacological treatment. All the "TS+ADHD" clinical group (48 subjects) showed after 10 years follow-up a different clinical phenotype: 62% "TS pure" phenotype, 35% "TS+OCD" phenotype, 2% "TS+ADHD+OCD" phenotype. Sixty-five percentage of the subject required pharmacological treatment. The "TS+ADHD+OCD" clinical group (14 subjects) after 10 years follow-up showed that 14% carried on with the same clinical phenotype, whereas 8.3% presented "TS pure" phenotype and 92% presented "TS+OCD" phenotype. Seventy-one percentage were in need of therapy. With regards to quality of life, patients presented widespread impairment correlated to the presence of comorbid conditions.
Our findings suggest that pure TS has quite a good long-term clinical course. By contrast, those who presented comorbid condition at the onset showed a more severe prognosis.
近期使用聚类分析和因子分析的研究表明,抽动秽语综合征(TS)不应再被视为一种单一的病症。
我们回顾性研究了100例TS患者的长期临床病程。在发病时及随访10年后对患者进行评估,以评估抽动严重程度、强迫症(OCD)、注意力缺陷多动障碍(ADHD)以及焦虑抑郁、暴怒发作、自伤行为的存在情况。此外,在随访时他们完成了一份生活质量评估量表,以评估患病10年后日常生活中的损害情况。
“单纯TS”临床组(38名受试者)在随访10年后显示,58%维持相同临床表型,而42%转变为“TS+OCD”表型。55%需要药物治疗。所有“TS+ADHD”临床组(48名受试者)在随访10年后显示出不同的临床表型:62%为“单纯TS”表型,35%为“TS+OCD”表型,2%为“TS+ADHD+OCD”表型。65%的受试者需要药物治疗。“TS+ADHD+OCD”临床组(14名受试者)在随访10年后显示,14%维持相同临床表型,而8.3%呈现“单纯TS”表型,92%呈现“TS+OCD”表型。71%需要治疗。关于生活质量,患者存在与共病情况相关的广泛损害。
我们的研究结果表明,单纯TS有相当好的长期临床病程。相比之下,发病时伴有共病的患者预后更差。