Matta and Harry Freund Neuropsychiatric Tourette Clinic, Schneider Children's Medical Center of Israel, Petach Tikva, affiliated with the Sackler Faculty of Medicine, Tel Aviv University, Tel Aviv, Israel.
Compr Psychiatry. 2013 Jul;54(5):467-73. doi: 10.1016/j.comppsych.2012.10.015. Epub 2012 Dec 6.
Tourette syndrome (TS) is a neuropsychiatric developmental disorder characterized by the presence of multiple motor tics and one or more vocal tics. Although TS is primarily biological in origin, stress-diatheses interactions most probably play a role in the course of the illness. The precise influence of the environment on this basically biological disorder is difficult to ascertain, particularly when TS is complicated by comorbidities. Among the many questions that remain unresolved are the differential impact of positive and negative events and specific subtypes of events, and the importance of major crucial events relative to minor daily ones to tic severity.
To examine the relationships between life events, tic severity and comorbid disorders in Tourette Syndrome (TS), including OCD, ADHD, anxiety, depression and rage attacks. Life events were classified by quantity, quality (positive or negative) and classification types of events (family, friends etc.).
Sixty patients aged 7-17 years with Tourette syndrome or a chronic tic disorder were recruited from Psychological Medicine Clinic in Schneider Children's Medical Center of Israel.
Yale Global Tic Severity Scale; Children's Yale Brown Obsessive Compulsive Scale; Life Experiences Survey; Brief Adolescent Life Events Scale; Screen for Child Anxiety Related Emotional Disorders; Child Depression Inventory/Beck Depression Inventory; ADHD Rating Scale IV; Overt Aggression Scale.
Regarding tics and minor life events, there was a weak but significant correlation between severity of motor tics and the quantity of negative events. No significant correlation was found between tic severity and quantity of positive events. Analysis of the BALES categories yielded a significant direct correlation between severity of vocal tics and quantity of negative events involving friends. Regarding comorbidities and minor life events, highly significant correlations were found with depression and anxiety. Regarding tics and major life events, significant correlation was found between the quantity of major life events and the severity of motor tics, but not vocal tics. Regarding comorbidities and major life events, significant correlation was found between the severity of compulsions, ADHD, and aggression and the subjects' personal evaluation of the effect of negative major life events on their lives.
Minor life events appear to be correlated with tic severity and comorbidities in children and adolescents with Tourette syndrome. The lack of an association between major life events and tic severity further emphasizes the salient impact of minor life events that occur in temporal proximity to the assessment of tic severity. Clinically, the results match our impression from patient narratives wherein they "blamed" the exacerbations in tics on social interactions. The high correlation between negative life events and depression, anxiety and compulsions symptoms, were reported also in previous studies. In conclusion, These findings may have clinical implications for planning supportive psychotherapy or cognitive behavioral therapy for this patient population.
妥瑞氏症(TS)是一种神经精神发育障碍,其特征为存在多种运动性抽搐和一种或多种发声性抽搐。尽管妥瑞氏症主要源于生物学,但压力-易感性相互作用很可能在疾病过程中发挥作用。环境对这种基本的生物学障碍的确切影响很难确定,尤其是当妥瑞氏症伴有合并症时。许多悬而未决的问题包括正性和负性事件以及特定类型事件的差异影响,以及重大关键事件相对于日常小事件对抽搐严重程度的重要性。
检查生活事件、抽搐严重程度和伴发疾病(包括强迫症、ADHD、焦虑症、抑郁症和愤怒发作)在妥瑞氏症(TS)中的关系。生活事件按数量、质量(正性或负性)和事件类型(家庭、朋友等)进行分类。
从以色列施耐德儿童医疗中心心理医学诊所招募了 60 名年龄在 7-17 岁的妥瑞氏症或慢性抽搐障碍患者。
耶鲁总体抽搐严重程度量表;儿童耶鲁布朗强迫症量表;生活经历量表;青少年生活事件量表简表;儿童焦虑相关情绪障碍筛查;儿童抑郁量表/贝克抑郁量表;ADHD 评定量表第四版;外显攻击量表。
关于抽搐和小的生活事件,运动性抽搐严重程度与负性事件数量之间存在微弱但显著的相关性。抽动严重程度与正性事件数量之间无显著相关性。BALES 类别的分析显示,发声性抽搐严重程度与涉及朋友的负性事件数量呈显著直接相关。关于合并症和小的生活事件,与抑郁症和焦虑症高度相关。关于抽搐和大的生活事件,大的生活事件数量与运动性抽搐严重程度之间存在显著相关性,但发声性抽搐无相关性。关于合并症和大的生活事件,强迫症、ADHD 和攻击性严重程度与受试者对负性大生活事件对其生活影响的个人评价之间存在显著相关性。
儿童和青少年妥瑞氏症患者的小的生活事件似乎与抽搐严重程度和合并症相关。大的生活事件与抽搐严重程度之间缺乏关联进一步强调了与评估抽搐严重程度时间接近的小的生活事件的突出影响。临床上,这些结果与我们从患者叙述中得到的印象相符,即他们“将抽搐加重归咎于社交互动”。以前的研究也报告了负性生活事件与抑郁、焦虑和强迫症症状之间的高度相关性。总之,这些发现可能对为该患者群体制定支持性心理治疗或认知行为治疗具有临床意义。