Department of Epidemiology, Boston University School of Public Health, Boston, MA, USA.
Epilepsy Behav. 2012 Jan;23(1):57-63. doi: 10.1016/j.yebeh.2011.11.002. Epub 2011 Dec 20.
We evaluated the validity of questions designed to identify lifetime and active epilepsy, medication use, and seizure occurrence on population-based surveys. Subjects were interviewed by telephone, and responses were compared with information in their medical records. Prevalence, sensitivity, specificity, and positive predictive value (PPV) were calculated. The prevalence of ever having been diagnosed with epilepsy was 3.1% by self-report and 2.7% by medical record review. Sensitivity was 84.2%, specificity was 99.2%, and PPV was 73.5% for self-reported lifetime epilepsy, and values were similar for active epilepsy. By comparison, sensitivity was higher and specificity was lower for epilepsy medication use and seizure occurrence. The PPV for seizure occurrence was substantially higher for a recall period of 12 months than for 3 months. These results compare favorably with results for other chronic conditions, such as diabetes and arthritis, and indicate that questionnaires can be used to identify epilepsy at a population level.
我们评估了旨在识别终身和活动性癫痫、用药情况和发作发生的问题在基于人群的调查中的有效性。通过电话对受试者进行访谈,并将其回答与他们的病历信息进行比较。计算了患病率、敏感性、特异性和阳性预测值(PPV)。通过自我报告和病历审查,癫痫的患病率分别为 3.1%和 2.7%。对于自我报告的终身癫痫,敏感性为 84.2%,特异性为 99.2%,PPV 为 73.5%,活动性癫痫的数值也相似。相比之下,癫痫药物使用和发作发生的敏感性更高,特异性更低。发作发生的 PPV 在 12 个月的回忆期内明显高于 3 个月。这些结果与糖尿病和关节炎等其他慢性疾病的结果相比表现良好,表明问卷调查可以用于在人群中识别癫痫。