International Centre for Circulatory Health, National Heart and Lung Institute, Imperial College, 59-61 North Wharf Road, London W21LA, UK.
Int J Cardiol. 2013 Jul 1;166(3):688-95. doi: 10.1016/j.ijcard.2011.11.104. Epub 2012 Jan 2.
Effective regurgitant orifice area (EROA) in mitral regurgitation (MR) is difficult to quantify. Clinically it is measured using the proximal isovelocity surface area (PISA) method, which is intrinsically not automatable, because it requires the operator to manually identify the mitral valve orifice. We introduce a new fully automated algorithm, ("AQURO"), which calculates EROA directly from echocardiographic colour M-mode data, without requiring operator input.
Multiple PISA measurements were compared to multiple AQURO measurements in twenty patients with MR. For PISA analysis, three mutually blinded observers measured EROA from the four stored video loops. For AQURO analysis, the software automatically processed the colour M-mode datasets and analysed the velocity field in the flow-convergence zone to extract EROA directly without any requirement for manual radius measurement.
Reproducibility, measured by intraclass correlation (ICC), for PISA was 0.80, 0.83 and 0.83 (for 3 observers respectively). Reproducibility for AQURO was 0.97. Agreement between replicate measurements calculated using Bland-Altman standard deviation of difference (SDD) was 21,17 and 17mm(2)for the three respective observers viewing independent video loops using PISA. Agreement between replicate measurements for AQURO was 6, 5 and 7mm(2)for automated analysis of the three pairs of datasets.
By eliminating the need to identify the orifice location, AQURO avoids an important source of measurement variability. Compared with PISA, it also reduces the analysis time allowing analysis and averaging of data from significantly more beats, improving the consistency of EROA quantification. AQURO, being fully automated, is a simple, effective enhancement for EROA quantification using standard echocardiographic equipment.
二尖瓣反流(MR)的有效瓣口面积(EROA)难以定量。临床上,它是使用近端等速表面积(PISA)方法测量的,该方法本质上不能自动化,因为它需要操作者手动识别二尖瓣瓣口。我们引入了一种新的全自动算法(“AQURO”),它可以直接从超声心动图彩色 M 型数据中计算 EROA,而无需操作者输入。
对 20 例 MR 患者的多次 PISA 测量值与多次 AQURO 测量值进行了比较。对于 PISA 分析,有 3 名相互盲目的观察者从 4 个存储的视频循环中测量 EROA。对于 AQURO 分析,软件自动处理彩色 M 型数据集,并分析流汇聚区的速度场,以直接提取 EROA,而无需任何手动半径测量。
观察者 3 分别进行 PISA 分析时,观察者内相关性(ICC)的可重复性为 0.80、0.83 和 0.83。AQURO 的可重复性为 0.97。使用 Bland-Altman 差值标准差(SDD)计算重复测量的一致性,3 名观察者分别观看独立视频循环使用 PISA 时,测量值分别为 21、17 和 17mm(2)。AQURO 自动分析 3 对数据集的重复测量值的一致性分别为 6、5 和 7mm(2)。
通过消除识别瓣口位置的需要,AQURO 避免了测量变异性的一个重要来源。与 PISA 相比,它还减少了分析时间,允许分析和平均来自更多心动周期的数据,从而提高了 EROA 定量的一致性。AQURO 是一种全自动的方法,它是使用标准超声心动图设备进行 EROA 定量的简单有效的增强方法。