Bauland Constantijn G, Smit Jeroen M, Scheffers Saskia M, Bartels Ronald H, van den Berg Paul, Zeebregts Clark J, Spauwen Paul H
Department of Plastic Surgery, Canisius Wilhelmina Hospital, Groningen, The Netherlands.
J Obstet Gynaecol Res. 2012 Feb;38(2):371-5. doi: 10.1111/j.1447-0756.2011.01717.x. Epub 2012 Jan 10.
In an earlier study we have shown that transcervical chorionic villus sampling in excess of 90 mg increases the risk for hemangiomas of infancy three- to four-fold compared to amniocentesis. In the present study we investigated whether transabdominal chorionic villus sampling (TA-CVS), in which the samples are smaller, carries the same risk.
Retrospectively, data were analyzed from 200 consecutive TA-CVS procedures and 200 consecutive amniocentesis procedures. Forty-two TA-CVS procedures and 27 amniocentesis procedures were excluded on predefined criteria. Questionnaires were sent to the parents asking if there was any skin mark on the child: vascular, pigmented or otherwise. All hemangiomas were clinically confirmed.
In the TA-CVS group, 118/158 questionnaires (75%), and in the amniocentesis group 134/173 questionnaires (77%) were returned. Based on the results of the questionnaire (i.e. mentioning of any skin lesion), 24 children in the TA-CVS group and 42 children in the amniocentesis group qualified for a physical examination. In the TA-CVS group 11/118 children (9%) had one or more hemangiomas. In the amniocentesis group 6/134 children (4%) had one or more hemangiomas. There was no statistical difference between the two groups (P = 0134).
These results suggest that TA-CVS does not cause an increase in the prevalence of hemangioma compared to amniocentesis. A larger series is, however, necessary to confirm this.
在一项早期研究中我们已经表明,与羊膜穿刺术相比,经宫颈绒毛取样超过90毫克会使婴儿期血管瘤的风险增加三到四倍。在本研究中,我们调查了经腹绒毛取样(TA - CVS)(其样本量较小)是否存在相同风险。
回顾性分析了连续200例TA - CVS手术和200例连续羊膜穿刺术的数据。根据预定标准排除了42例TA - CVS手术和27例羊膜穿刺术。向父母发送问卷,询问孩子是否有任何皮肤印记:血管性、色素沉着性或其他类型。所有血管瘤均经临床确诊。
在TA - CVS组中,158份问卷中有118份(75%)被返回,在羊膜穿刺术组中,173份问卷中有134份(77%)被返回。根据问卷结果(即提及任何皮肤病变),TA - CVS组中有24名儿童和羊膜穿刺术组中有42名儿童符合体格检查条件。在TA - CVS组中,118名儿童中有11名(9%)有一个或多个血管瘤。在羊膜穿刺术组中,134名儿童中有6名(4%)有一个或多个血管瘤。两组之间无统计学差异(P = 0.134)。
这些结果表明,与羊膜穿刺术相比,TA - CVS不会导致血管瘤患病率增加。然而,需要更大规模的系列研究来证实这一点。