Discipline of Public Health, University of Adelaide, South Australia.
J Telemed Telecare. 2012 Mar;18(2):109-14. doi: 10.1258/jtt.2011.110808. Epub 2012 Jan 20.
We examined how Australian telehealth service providers perceived and addressed ethical, medico-legal and clinical governance matters arising from service delivery. Thirty-seven telehealth clinicians and managers were interviewed and a qualitative content analysis was conducted. The services covered six Australian jurisdictions and a range of clinical disciplines. There were 11 medical specialities, surgery, mental health, paediatrics, nursing and allied health. Thirty services (83%) used video consulting and 25 (68%) delivered services to rural areas. Telehealth was reported to be beneficial by reducing adverse events, improving health outcomes, offering increased patient choice of service delivery, and improving access to services for rural areas and home care. There were observations of gains or no change in patient-provider rapport compared to face-to-face communication, with some patients reportedly preferring video. Those interviewed reported some problems with privacy and security, and variable informed consent practices. No examples of malpractice were raised, although there was a common misperception that distant providers were not responsible for clinical care. With respect to clinical governance, telehealth was seen as enabling improved quality, integration and implementation of evidence-based care, and to be a major support for the rural health workforce. Although there were potential ethical, medico-legal and governance problems in Australian telehealth services, these had been easily managed in practice.
我们研究了澳大利亚远程医疗服务提供商如何感知和处理服务提供过程中出现的伦理、医疗法律和临床治理问题。对 37 名远程医疗临床医生和管理人员进行了访谈,并进行了定性内容分析。这些服务涵盖了澳大利亚的六个司法管辖区和一系列临床学科。有 11 个医学专业,包括外科、心理健康、儿科、护理和联合健康。30 项服务(83%)使用视频咨询,25 项服务(68%)提供给农村地区。远程医疗被认为具有减少不良事件、改善健康结果、为患者提供更多服务交付选择以及改善农村地区和家庭护理服务的可及性等益处。与面对面交流相比,患者与提供者的关系有所改善或没有变化,一些患者据说更喜欢视频。受访者报告说,存在一些隐私和安全问题,以及知情同意实践的差异。虽然存在一些普遍的误解,即远程提供者不负责临床护理,但没有出现医疗事故的例子。在临床治理方面,远程医疗被视为能够提高基于证据的护理的质量、整合和实施,并为农村卫生劳动力提供主要支持。尽管澳大利亚的远程医疗服务存在潜在的伦理、医疗法律和治理问题,但这些问题在实践中很容易得到管理。