Vogel Timothy W, Menezes Arnold H
Department of Neurosurgery, Children's Hospital Boston, Harvard Medical School, Harvard University, Boston, MA 02115, USA.
Childs Nerv Syst. 2012 Apr;28(4):609-19. doi: 10.1007/s00381-012-1694-z. Epub 2012 Jan 25.
Chondrodysplasia punctata (CDP) is a group of skeletal dysplasias manifesting with progressive cervical instability that leads to neurological deficits and eventual death. The major clinical features of CDP also present in a phenocopy known as coumarin embryopathy (CE) which results from coumarin exposure during pregnancy. The objective of this study was to assess treatment strategies employed for children affected by CDP or CE with cervical instability and to determine a strategy on how best to diagnose and treat affected neonates.
We performed a systematic review of the English literature for cases reporting cervical spine involvement in CDP and CE and identified 44 such patients. We extracted clinical information on these disorders and identified two patients from our craniovertebral junction database of over 6,000 patients evaluated at our institution.
Patients most frequently present with hyperreflexia (21%) and weakness (21%), and there were various conservative treatment strategies. Twenty-one percent of patients who were treated conservatively had neurological complications in their clinical course. There were two deaths reported, one resulting from conservative treatment and one from surgical treatment. We also report long-term follow-up analysis for a patient treated at our institution for the last 30 years and agree with all other reports that suggest that monitoring patients for neurological changes is essential to prevent further neurological injury.
This study emphasizes the need for careful neurological and surgical evaluation of pediatric patients with cervical spine abnormalities affected by CDP or CE in order to prevent progressive instability.
点状软骨发育不良(CDP)是一组骨骼发育异常疾病,表现为进行性颈椎不稳,可导致神经功能缺损并最终死亡。CDP的主要临床特征也见于一种称为香豆素胚胎病(CE)的表型相似疾病,该病是由孕期接触香豆素引起的。本研究的目的是评估针对患有颈椎不稳的CDP或CE患儿所采用的治疗策略,并确定如何最好地诊断和治疗受影响新生儿的策略。
我们对英文文献进行了系统回顾,以查找报告CDP和CE颈椎受累情况的病例,共识别出44例此类患者。我们提取了这些疾病的临床信息,并从我们机构评估的6000多名患者的颅颈交界数据库中识别出2例患者。
患者最常出现的症状为反射亢进(21%)和肌无力(21%),并且存在多种保守治疗策略。接受保守治疗的患者中有21%在临床过程中出现神经并发症。报告了2例死亡病例,1例死于保守治疗,1例死于手术治疗。我们还报告了在我们机构接受治疗达30年的1例患者的长期随访分析,并且同意所有其他报告的观点,即监测患者的神经变化对于预防进一步的神经损伤至关重要。
本研究强调,对于受CDP或CE影响而出现颈椎异常的儿科患者,需要进行仔细的神经学和外科评估,以防止病情进展为颈椎不稳。