Department of Radiation Oncology, Fudan University Shanghai Cancer Center, 270 Dong An Road, Shanghai, 200032, China.
Radiat Oncol. 2012 Jan 30;7:11. doi: 10.1186/1748-717X-7-11.
To evaluate the accuracy of the combined maximum and minimum intensity projection-based internal target volume (ITV) delineation in 4-dimensional (4D) CT scans for liver malignancies.
4D CT with synchronized IV contrast data were acquired from 15 liver cancer patients (4 hepatocellular carcinomas; 11 hepatic metastases). We used five approaches to determine ITVs: (1). ITVAllPhases: contouring gross tumor volume (GTV) on each of 10 respiratory phases of 4D CT data set and combining these GTVs; (2). ITV2Phase: contouring GTV on CT of the peak inhale phase (0% phase) and the peak exhale phase (50%) and then combining the two; (3). ITVMIP: contouring GTV on MIP with modifications based on physician's visual verification of contours in each respiratory phase; (4). ITVMinIP: contouring GTV on MinIP with modification by physician; (5). ITV2M: combining ITVMIP and ITVMinIP. ITVAllPhases was taken as the reference ITV, and the metrics used for comparison were: matching index (MI), under- and over-estimated volume (Vunder and Vover).
4D CT images were successfully acquired from 15 patients and tumor margins were clearly discernable in all patients. There were 9 cases of low density and 6, mixed on CT images. After comparisons of metrics, the tool of ITV2M was the most appropriate to contour ITV for liver malignancies with the highest MI of 0.93 ± 0.04 and the lowest proportion of Vunder (0.07 ± 0.04). Moreover, tumor volume, target motion three-dimensionally and ratio of tumor vertical diameter over tumor motion magnitude in cranio-caudal direction did not significantly influence the values of MI and proportion of Vunder.
The tool of ITV2M is recommended as a reliable method for generating ITVs from 4D CT data sets in liver cancer.
评估基于最大和最小强度投影的联合内部靶区(ITV)在肝恶性肿瘤 4 维(4D)CT 扫描中的勾画准确性。
从 15 例肝癌患者(4 例肝细胞癌;11 例肝转移)中获取 4D CT 扫描和同步 IV 造影数据。我们使用五种方法来确定 ITV:(1)ITVAllPhases:在 4D CT 数据集的 10 个呼吸相位中的每个相位上勾画大体肿瘤体积(GTV),并将这些 GTV 结合起来;(2)ITV2Phase:在 CT 的吸气峰相(0%相位)和呼气峰相(50%相位)上勾画 GTV,然后将两者结合起来;(3)ITVMIP:根据医生在每个呼吸相位中对轮廓的视觉验证,对 MIP 上的 GTV 进行修改后进行勾画;(4)ITVMinIP:由医生对 MinIP 上的 GTV 进行修改后进行勾画;(5)ITV2M:将 ITVMIP 和 ITVMinIP 结合起来。以 ITVAllPhases 为参考 ITV,比较的指标为:匹配指数(MI)、低估和高估体积(Vunder 和 Vover)。
成功获取了 15 例患者的 4D CT 图像,所有患者的肿瘤边缘均清晰可见。CT 图像上有 9 例为低密度,6 例为混合密度。比较指标后,ITV2M 工具最适合勾画肝恶性肿瘤的 ITV,MI 最高为 0.93 ± 0.04,低估比例(Vunder)最低为 0.07 ± 0.04。此外,肿瘤体积、靶区三维运动和肿瘤垂直直径与肿瘤运动幅度在头尾方向上的比值对 MI 值和低估比例(Vunder)的影响无统计学意义。
推荐 ITV2M 工具作为从肝癌 4D CT 数据集生成 ITV 的可靠方法。