Niittynen Leena, Pitkäranta Anne, Korpela Riitta
Nutritionist Leena Niittynen, Kantotie 9, 03400 Vihti, Finland.
Int J Pediatr Otorhinolaryngol. 2012 Apr;76(4):465-70. doi: 10.1016/j.ijporl.2012.01.011. Epub 2012 Feb 2.
An alternative option in the prophylaxis and the management of infectious diseases is the use of probiotics, which are known to stabilize gut microbiota and stimulate immune function. Otitis media (OM) is the most common bacterial infection in childhood. The aim of this review is to present the current knowledge of the effects of probiotics on OM.
A PUBMED search was made to review the relevant literature, and publications on probiotics and otitis media in children were included. Additional studies were obtained from the references of the selected articles.
Only a few studies using different probiotic strains and study populations have investigated the effects of probiotics on OM. Five studies investigating the effects of oral probiotics, and three studies investigating the effect of probiotic nasal spray treatment were included in this review. Oral probiotics have reduced the incidence of OM in healthy children in one of two studies (days with OM: probiotic 0.5 vs. control 1.0; p=0.003) and in newborns in one of two studies (incidence of OM: probiotic 22%, placebo 50%; p=0.014), but has had no effect on OM in one study in otitis prone children. Nasal spray treatment containing α streptococci has led to clinical improvement in children with recurrent or secretory OM in two of three studies (cured: probiotic 42% vs. placebo 22%, p=0.02; recovery: probiotic 7/19 patients vs. placebo 1/17, p<0.05).
Although there are some promising results, the lack of confirmative studies makes it difficult to draw any conclusions. More studies are needed to identify the most promising probiotic strains and study populations, and to evaluate the mechanisms behind the possible effects of probiotics on OM.
预防和管理传染病的一种替代选择是使用益生菌,已知其可稳定肠道微生物群并刺激免疫功能。中耳炎(OM)是儿童期最常见的细菌感染。本综述的目的是介绍益生菌对中耳炎影响的当前知识。
进行了一项PubMed检索以回顾相关文献,并纳入了关于儿童益生菌和中耳炎的出版物。从所选文章的参考文献中获取了其他研究。
仅有少数使用不同益生菌菌株和研究人群的研究调查了益生菌对中耳炎的影响。本综述纳入了五项调查口服益生菌效果的研究,以及三项调查益生菌鼻喷雾剂治疗效果的研究。在两项研究中的一项中,口服益生菌降低了健康儿童中耳炎的发病率(患中耳炎天数:益生菌组0.5天,对照组1.0天;p = 0.003),在两项研究中的一项中降低了新生儿中耳炎的发病率(中耳炎发病率:益生菌组22%,安慰剂组50%;p = 0.014),但在一项针对易患中耳炎儿童的研究中对中耳炎没有影响。含α链球菌的鼻喷雾剂治疗在三项研究中的两项中使复发性或分泌性中耳炎儿童的病情得到了临床改善(治愈:益生菌组42%,安慰剂组22%,p = 0.02;好转:益生菌组19例中有7例,安慰剂组17例中有1例,p < 0.05)。
尽管有一些有前景的结果,但缺乏确证性研究使得难以得出任何结论。需要更多研究来确定最有前景的益生菌菌株和研究人群,并评估益生菌对中耳炎可能产生影响背后的机制。