Binbay Tolga, Ulaş Halis, Alptekin Köksal, Elbi Hayriye
Atatürk Public Hospital, Psychiatry Unit, Sinop.
Turk Psikiyatri Derg. 2012 Spring;23(1):53-62.
To provide an overview of incidence and prevalence estimates, admission rates, and related features of psychotic disorders among immigrants from Turkey in Western Europe.
Articles published in all languages between 1990 and 2010 were included. In order to detect relevant studies, a string ([schizo* OR psych*] AND [Turk*] AND [migra* OR immigra*]) was used in MEDLINE and PsychINFO. Turkish indexes and abstracts books of national congresses were also screened to locate additional papers.
We included 21 studies which yielded 25 rates on psychotic disorders among immigrants from Turkey. Fifteen papers reported rates for the immigrants from Turkey in The Netherlands, four for Germany, one for Denmark and one for Switzerland. The incidence estimates of non-affective and affective psychosis among immigrants from Turkey were between 38.5 and 44.9 per 100,000 while incidence estimates of schizophrenia were between 12.4 and 63.8 per 100,000. The prevalence estimates of schizophrenia and other psychotic disorders were between 1.1 and 6.2 per 1,000. Rates and relative risks of psychotic disorders in immigrants from Turkey tended to be higher than the natives and lower than other immigrant groups with similar sociocultural background. In addition to other risk factors, social contextual factors including discrimination and neighbourhood characteristics were the key environmental factors that modulate rates of psychotic disorders among immigrants from Turkey. Males were under a higher risk of incidence, prevalence estimates, and admission rates.
Variations in rates and relative risks indicate a possible etiological role of social experiences in immigrants. Studies with a focus on comparing the rates and the social factors of psychotic disorders between immigrants from Turkey in Western Europe and their family members residing in Turkey may provide additional insight into the epidemiology of psychotic disorders.
概述西欧地区来自土耳其的移民中精神障碍的发病率、患病率、住院率及相关特征。
纳入1990年至2010年间以各种语言发表的文章。为检索相关研究,在MEDLINE和PsychINFO数据库中使用检索式([精神分裂症或精神] AND [土耳其*] AND [移民或移居])。还查阅了土耳其语索引及全国大会的摘要书籍以查找其他论文。
我们纳入了21项研究,这些研究得出了25个关于来自土耳其移民的精神障碍发病率。15篇论文报告了荷兰的土耳其移民发病率,4篇报告了德国的,1篇报告了丹麦的,1篇报告了瑞士的。来自土耳其的移民中非情感性和情感性精神病的发病率估计为每10万人38.5至44.9例,而精神分裂症的发病率估计为每10万人12.4至63.8例。精神分裂症和其他精神障碍的患病率估计为每1000人1.1至6.2例。来自土耳其的移民中精神障碍的发病率和相对风险往往高于本地人,但低于具有相似社会文化背景的其他移民群体。除其他风险因素外,包括歧视和邻里特征在内的社会环境因素是调节来自土耳其的移民中精神障碍发病率的关键环境因素。男性在发病率、患病率估计和住院率方面风险更高。
发病率和相对风险的差异表明社会经历在移民中可能具有病因学作用。聚焦于比较西欧来自土耳其的移民与其居住在土耳其的家庭成员之间精神障碍发病率及社会因素的研究,可能会为精神障碍的流行病学提供更多见解。