Learning Research and Development Center, University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, USA.
Hum Brain Mapp. 2013 Jul;34(7):1670-84. doi: 10.1002/hbm.22017. Epub 2012 Feb 29.
We examined the hypothesis that learning to write Chinese characters influences the brain's reading network for characters. Students from a college Chinese class learned 30 characters in a character-writing condition and 30 characters in a pinyin-writing condition. After learning, functional magnetic resonance imaging collected during passive viewing showed different networks for reading Chinese characters and English words, suggesting accommodation to the demands of the new writing system through short-term learning. Beyond these expected differences, we found specific effects of character writing in greater activation (relative to pinyin writing) in bilateral superior parietal lobules and bilateral lingual gyri in both a lexical decision and an implicit writing task. These findings suggest that character writing establishes a higher quality representation of the visual-spatial structure of the character and its orthography. We found a greater involvement of bilateral sensori-motor cortex (SMC) for character-writing trained characters than pinyin-writing trained characters in the lexical decision task, suggesting that learning by doing invokes greater interaction with sensori-motor information during character recognition. Furthermore, we found a correlation of recognition accuracy with activation in right superior parietal lobule, right lingual gyrus, and left SMC, suggesting that these areas support the facilitative effect character writing has on reading. Finally, consistent with previous behavioral studies, we found character-writing training facilitates connections with semantics by producing greater activation in bilateral middle temporal gyri, whereas pinyin-writing training facilitates connections with phonology by producing greater activation in right inferior frontal gyrus.
我们检验了这样一个假设,即学习书写汉字会影响大脑对汉字的阅读网络。来自大学中文班的学生在汉字书写条件下学习 30 个汉字,在拼音书写条件下学习 30 个汉字。学习后,在被动观看时采集的功能磁共振成像显示,阅读汉字和英语单词的网络不同,这表明通过短期学习适应了新书写系统的要求。除了这些预期的差异之外,我们还发现了特定的汉字书写效应,即在词汇判断和内隐书写任务中,双侧顶叶上回和双侧舌回的激活(相对于拼音书写)更大。这些发现表明,汉字书写建立了一个更高质量的汉字视觉空间结构及其正字法的表示。在词汇判断任务中,与拼音书写训练的汉字相比,我们发现双侧感觉运动皮层(SMC)对汉字书写训练的汉字有更大的参与,这表明通过实践学习在汉字识别过程中会引起与感觉运动信息更大的相互作用。此外,我们发现识别准确率与右顶叶、右舌回和左 SMC 的激活呈正相关,这表明这些区域支持汉字书写对阅读的促进作用。最后,与之前的行为研究一致,我们发现汉字书写训练通过在双侧颞中回产生更大的激活,促进了与语义的联系,而拼音书写训练通过在右额下回产生更大的激活,促进了与语音的联系。