Department of Surgery, Scheper Ziekenhuis Emmen, University Medical Center Groningen, University of Groningen, Groningen, The Netherlands.
J Crohns Colitis. 2012 Jul;6(6):637-46. doi: 10.1016/j.crohns.2011.12.006. Epub 2012 Jan 9.
Up to 75% of patients with Crohn's disease (CD) will have intestinal resection during their life. Most patients will, however, develop postoperative recurrence (endoscopic, clinical or surgical). Several medical and surgical strategies have been attempted to prevent postoperative recurrence. This review evaluates the efficacy of different drug regimens and surgical techniques in the prevention of clinical, endoscopic and surgical postoperative recurrence of CD.
A literature search for randomized controlled trials on medical or surgical interventions was performed. The endpoints for efficacy were clinical, endoscopic and surgical recurrence. Meta-analyses were performed in case two or more RCTs evaluated the same drug or surgical technique.
Mesalamine is more effective in preventing clinical recurrence than placebo (P=0,012), as well as nitroimidazolic antibiotics at one year follow-up (P<0.001) and thiopurines (P=0.018). Nitroimidazolic antibiotics are also more effective than placebo in preventing endoscopic recurrence (P=0.037), as well as thiopurines (P=0.015) and infliximab (P=0.006). Budenoside, probiotics, Interleukin-10 nor any of the different surgical procedures showed any significant difference compared to placebo in postoperative recurrence rates of CD.
Among the different drug regimens and surgical techniques, only thiopurines and nitroimidazolic antibiotics are able to reduce postoperative clinical as well as endoscopic recurrence of CD. Mesalamine and infliximab also seem to be superior to placebo in preventing clinical recurrence and endoscopic recurrence, respectively. There is a paucity of trials evaluating long-term follow-up and prevention of surgical recurrence of CD.
多达 75%的克罗恩病(CD)患者在其一生中需要进行肠道切除术。然而,大多数患者会出现术后复发(内镜、临床或手术)。已经尝试了几种医学和手术策略来预防术后复发。本综述评估了不同药物方案和手术技术在预防 CD 术后临床、内镜和手术复发方面的疗效。
对医学或手术干预的随机对照试验进行了文献检索。疗效的终点是临床、内镜和手术复发。如果两个或更多 RCT 评估了相同的药物或手术技术,则进行荟萃分析。
美沙拉嗪在预防临床复发方面比安慰剂更有效(P=0.012),在一年随访时也比硝基咪唑类抗生素更有效(P<0.001)和硫嘌呤类药物(P=0.018)。硝基咪唑类抗生素在预防内镜复发方面也比安慰剂更有效(P=0.037),以及硫嘌呤类药物(P=0.015)和英夫利昔单抗(P=0.006)。布地奈德、益生菌、白细胞介素-10 以及任何不同的手术程序与安慰剂相比,在 CD 的术后复发率方面均无显著差异。
在不同的药物方案和手术技术中,只有硫嘌呤类药物和硝基咪唑类抗生素能够降低 CD 的术后临床和内镜复发率。美沙拉嗪和英夫利昔单抗似乎也分别在预防临床复发和内镜复发方面优于安慰剂。目前评估 CD 长期随访和预防手术复发的试验较少。