Department of Orthopaedics and Rehabilitation, Vanderbilt University Medical Center, Nashville, TN, USA.
Bone. 2012 Jun;50(6):1357-67. doi: 10.1016/j.bone.2012.03.008. Epub 2012 Mar 17.
The mouse fracture model is ideal for research into the pathways of healing because of the availability of genetic and transgenic mice and the ability to create cell-specific genetic mutations. While biomechanical tests and histology are available to assess callus integrity and tissue differentiation, respectively, micro-computed tomography (μCT) analysis has increasingly been utilized in fracture studies because it is non-destructive and provides descriptions of the structural and compositional properties of the callus. However, the dynamic changes of μCT properties that occur during healing are not well defined. Thus, the purpose of this study was to determine which μCT properties change with the progression of fracture repair and converge to values similar to unfractured bone in the mouse femur fracture model. A unilateral femur fracture was performed in C57BL/6 mice and intramedullary fixation performed. Fractured and un-fractured contralateral specimens were harvested from groups of mice between 2 and 12 weeks post-fracture. Parameters describing callus based on μCT were obtained, including polar moment of inertia (J), bending moment of inertia (I), total volume (TV), tissue mineral density (TMD), total bone volume fraction (BV/TV), and volumetric bone mineral density (vBMD). For comparison, plain radiographs were used to measure the callus diameter (D) and area (A); and biomechanical properties were evaluated using either three-point bending or torsion. The μCT parameters J, I, TV, and TMD converged toward their respective values of the un-fractured femurs over time, although significant differences existed between the two sides at every time point evaluated (p<0.05). Radiograph measurement D changed with repair progression in similar manner to TV. In contrast, BV/TV and BMD increased and decreased over time with statistical differences between callus and un-fractured bone occurring sporadically. Similarly, none of the biomechanical properties were found to distinguish consistently between the fractured and un-fractured femur. Micro-CT parameters assessing callus structure and size (J, I, and TV) were more sensitive to changes in callus over time post-fracture than those assessing callus substance (TMD, BV/TV, and BMD). Sample size estimates based on these results indicate that utilization of μCT requires fewer animals than biomechanics and thus is more practical for evaluating the healing femur in the mouse fracture model.
小鼠骨折模型是研究愈合途径的理想模型,因为它具有遗传和转基因小鼠的可用性,以及创建细胞特异性基因突变的能力。虽然生物力学测试和组织学可分别用于评估骨痂的完整性和组织分化,但微计算机断层扫描 (μCT) 分析已越来越多地用于骨折研究,因为它是非破坏性的,并提供了骨痂结构和组成特性的描述。然而,愈合过程中 μCT 特性的动态变化尚不清楚。因此,本研究的目的是确定哪些 μCT 特性随骨折修复的进展而变化,并与小鼠股骨骨折模型中未骨折的骨相似。在 C57BL/6 小鼠中进行单侧股骨骨折,并进行髓内固定。在骨折后 2 至 12 周的不同时间点,从各组小鼠中取出骨折和未骨折的对侧标本。使用 μCT 获得描述骨痂的参数,包括极惯性矩 (J)、弯曲惯性矩 (I)、总体积 (TV)、组织矿物质密度 (TMD)、总骨体积分数 (BV/TV) 和体积骨矿物质密度 (vBMD)。为了进行比较,使用普通 X 射线测量骨痂的直径 (D) 和面积 (A);并使用三点弯曲或扭转来评估生物力学特性。随着时间的推移,μCT 参数 J、I、TV 和 TMD 逐渐接近未骨折股骨的相应值,尽管在评估的每个时间点两侧之间仍存在显著差异 (p<0.05)。X 射线测量的 D 随着修复进展以与 TV 相似的方式变化。相比之下,BV/TV 和 BMD 随着时间的推移而增加和减少,骨痂和未骨折骨之间的统计学差异偶尔发生。同样,没有一种生物力学特性能够始终如一地区分骨折和未骨折的股骨。评估骨痂结构和大小的 μCT 参数(J、I 和 TV)比评估骨痂物质的参数(TMD、BV/TV 和 BMD)对骨折后骨痂随时间的变化更敏感。基于这些结果的样本量估计表明,与生物力学相比,μCT 的使用需要更少的动物,因此更适合于评估小鼠骨折模型中的愈合股骨。