Ganschow P
Chirurgische Universitätsklinik, Klinik für Allgemein-, Viszeral- und Transplantationschirurgie, Heidelberg, Deutschland.
Zentralbl Chir. 2012 Apr;137(2):113-7. doi: 10.1055/s-0031-1283983. Epub 2012 Apr 11.
Within the last few years several reports have observed an increasing decline of interest for medical students to become a general surgeon. A recent study among medical students from five medical schools in South-West Germany revealed that only 8.9 % of the students were considering a surgical career. In addition, the authors showed that there was a severe decrease of interest in a surgical career throughout medical school. The aim of the presented study is to analyse career preferences of medical students in several countries.
A Medline search for "surgical career", "medical students + general surgery" and "surgical career + influences" was performed.
There are similar situations to that in Germany in the USA, Great Britain, New Zeeland and Switzerland with small proportions of medical students inclined towards a surgical career. In Kenya, Jordan, Pakistan and Iraq at least a higher percentage of male medical students favoured a surgical career. Independent of the country, more male medical students are pursuing a surgical career. Studies from different countries reported an increasing loss of interest in a surgical career throughout medical school. Positive influencing factors for specialisation in a field of surgery were identified: These are independent of the country, positive experiences in practical courses and positive role models.
Further studies to analyse factors influencing students throughout medical school are required in the future. Internships, special tutorials, and final year rotations should be used to develop individual mentoring programmes to increase the student's interest in pursuing a general surgical career.
在过去几年里,有几份报告指出,医学生对成为普通外科医生的兴趣日益下降。最近一项针对德国西南部五所医学院校医学生的研究显示,只有8.9%的学生考虑从事外科职业。此外,作者还表明,在整个医学院学习期间,学生对外科职业的兴趣大幅下降。本研究的目的是分析几个国家医学生的职业偏好。
在Medline数据库中检索了“外科职业”“医学生+普通外科”以及“外科职业+影响因素”。
在美国、英国、新西兰和瑞士,情况与德国类似,倾向于从事外科职业的医学生比例很小。在肯尼亚、约旦、巴基斯坦和伊拉克,至少有较高比例的男医学生青睐外科职业。无论在哪个国家,从事外科职业的男医学生更多。来自不同国家的研究报告称,在整个医学院学习期间,学生对外科职业的兴趣不断下降。已确定了对外科领域专业化有积极影响的因素:这些因素与国家无关,包括实践课程中的积极体验和正面榜样。
未来需要进一步开展研究,分析在整个医学院学习期间影响学生的因素。应利用实习、专门辅导和最后一年的轮转安排来制定个性化的指导计划,以提高学生从事普通外科职业的兴趣。