MacWilliams H K, Bonner J T
Differentiation. 1979;14(1-2):1-22. doi: 10.1111/j.1432-0436.1979.tb01006.x.
In cellular slime molds the slugs become divided into two regions with different properties, and anterior prestalk-zone and a posterior prespore zone. Although the cells in these zones are normally destined to form the stalk cells and spores of the fruiting body, respectively, they are not irreversibly committed to one sort of differentiation or the other during the slug stage. The volume ratio of the two zones remains almost constant over a wide range of slug sizes. If the prestalk-prespore pattern is distrubed by removing tissue from the slug, conversion of tissue from prestalk to prespore or vice versa occurs as necessary to restore a normal pattern with normal proportions. Conversions also occur in both directions during normal development. The initial formation of the prestalk-prespore pattern may well involve sorting-out, but other mechanisms must be invoked to account for regulation. We describe three different models of the generation of the prestalk-prespore pattern, the'cell-contact model' of McMahon, in which pattern is created by interactions of cells with their immediate neighbors, the 'positional-information model' of various authors, in which pattern formation involves an overall gradient and a gradient-reading mechanism, and the 'activator-inhibitor model' of Gierer and Meinhardt, in which the prestalk-prespore pattern is formed by a system of diffusible substances that affect one another's production. The activator-inhibitor model is the most successful of the models at describing the known features of the prestalk-prespore pattern. The various models lead to a number of distinctive predictions. According to the cell-contact model, small transplants may cause gross changes in the prestalk-prespore pattern, and mutants may exist which severely disrupt pattern formation even if diluted with a large excess of wild-type cells. Positional-information models predict the existence of 'gradient-reading mutants'; slugs that are a mixture of such mutants and wild-type cells would show two prestalk-prespore boundaries, one at the mutant and one at the normal position. Both the activator-inhibitor model and some versions of the positional-information model predict that small transplants will sometimes induce accessory prestalk or prespore zones; the quantitative characteristics of these effects may allow one to make a case in favor of one or other of the two models. Finally, the activator-inhibitor model leads one to expect that mutants may be isolated which normally show accessory prestalk or prespore zones. A search for these phenomena may help determine whether the activator-inhibitor model will continue to enjoy its present preeminent position.
在细胞黏菌中,蛞蝓状幼体分为两个具有不同特性的区域,一个是前部的柄细胞前体区,另一个是后部的孢子前体区。虽然这些区域的细胞通常分别注定要形成子实体的柄细胞和孢子,但在蛞蝓状幼体阶段,它们并非不可逆转地固定为一种分化类型。在很大范围的蛞蝓状幼体大小中,这两个区域的体积比几乎保持恒定。如果通过从蛞蝓状幼体中移除组织来扰乱柄细胞前体 - 孢子前体模式,那么柄细胞前体组织向孢子前体组织或反之的转变会根据需要发生,以恢复具有正常比例的正常模式。在正常发育过程中,两个方向的转变也会发生。柄细胞前体 - 孢子前体模式的最初形成很可能涉及细胞分选,但必须调用其他机制来解释调控过程。我们描述了三种不同的柄细胞前体 - 孢子前体模式生成模型,麦克马洪的“细胞接触模型”,其中模式是由细胞与其直接相邻细胞的相互作用产生的;不同作者提出的“位置信息模型”,其中模式形成涉及一个整体梯度和一个梯度读取机制;以及吉勒尔和迈因哈特的“激活 - 抑制模型”,其中柄细胞前体 - 孢子前体模式是由一种相互影响彼此产生的可扩散物质系统形成的。激活 - 抑制模型在描述柄细胞前体 - 孢子前体模式的已知特征方面是最成功的模型。各种模型导致了许多独特的预测。根据细胞接触模型,小的移植可能会导致柄细胞前体 - 孢子前体模式发生重大变化,并且可能存在即使与大量野生型细胞混合稀释也会严重破坏模式形成的突变体。位置信息模型预测存在“梯度读取突变体”;由这些突变体和野生型细胞混合组成的蛞蝓状幼体会显示两个柄细胞前体 - 孢子前体边界,一个在突变体处,一个在正常位置。激活 - 抑制模型和一些版本的位置信息模型都预测小的移植有时会诱导附属的柄细胞前体或孢子前体区域;这些效应的定量特征可能会让人支持这两个模型中的一个或另一个。最后,激活 - 抑制模型让人预期可能会分离出通常显示附属柄细胞前体或孢子前体区域的突变体。对这些现象的研究可能有助于确定激活 - 抑制模型是否会继续保持其目前的卓越地位。