Department of Archaeology, Croatian Academy of Sciences and Arts, Zagreb, Croatia.
Am J Phys Anthropol. 2012 Sep;149(1):26-38. doi: 10.1002/ajpa.22083. Epub 2012 May 3.
To test the historically documented hypothesis of a general increase in deliberate violence in the eastern Adriatic from the antique (AN; 2nd-6th c.) through the early medieval (EM; 7th-11th c.) to the late-medieval period (LM; 12th-16th c.), an analysis of the frequency and patterning of bone trauma was conducted in three skeletal series from these time periods. A total of 1,125 adult skeletons-346 from the AN, 313 from the EM, and 466 from the LM series-were analyzed. To differentiate between intentional violence and accidental injuries, data for trauma frequencies were collected for the complete skeleton, individual long bones, and the craniofacial region as well as by type of injury (perimortem vs. antemortem). The results of our analyses show a significant temporal increase in total fracture frequencies when calculated by skeleton as well as of individuals exhibiting one skeletal indicator of deliberate violence (sharp force lesions, craniofacial injuries, "parry" fractures, or perimortem trauma). No significant temporal increases were, however, noted in the frequencies of craniofacial trauma, "parry" fractures, perimortem injuries, or of individuals exhibiting multiple skeletal indicators of intentional violence. Cumulatively, these data suggest that the temporal increase in total fracture frequencies recorded in the eastern Adriatic was caused by a combination of factors that included not only an increase of intentional violence but also a significant change in lifestyle that accompanied the transition from a relatively affluent AN urban lifestyle to a more primitive rural medieval way of life.
为了验证从古代(AN;公元 2 世纪至 6 世纪)到早期中世纪(EM;公元 7 世纪至 11 世纪)再到晚中世纪(LM;公元 12 世纪至 16 世纪)在东亚得里亚海地区蓄意暴力普遍增加的历史记录假说,对来自这些时期的三个骨骼系列的骨创伤频率和模式进行了分析。总共分析了 1125 具成年骨骼 - 346 具来自 AN,313 具来自 EM,466 具来自 LM 系列。为了区分故意暴力和意外损伤,对创伤频率的数据进行了收集,包括完整骨骼、单个长骨以及颅面区域,以及损伤类型(濒死期与生前)。我们的分析结果表明,当按骨骼或个体计算时,总骨折频率以及表现出一种蓄意暴力骨骼指标(锐器伤、颅面损伤、“招架”骨折或濒死期创伤)的个体的骨折频率都有明显的时间增加。然而,颅面创伤、“招架”骨折、濒死期损伤或表现出多种故意暴力骨骼指标的个体的频率并没有明显的时间增加。总的来说,这些数据表明,在东亚得里亚记录的总骨折频率的时间增加是由多种因素共同造成的,不仅包括故意暴力的增加,还包括与从相对富裕的 AN 城市生活方式向更原始的中世纪农村生活方式转变相伴而来的生活方式的重大变化。