Department of Anesthesiology, University Hospital Aachen, RWTH Aachen University, Aachen, Germany.
PLoS One. 2012;7(5):e36796. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0036796. Epub 2012 May 18.
Inter-hospital teleconsultation improves stroke care. To transfer this concept into the emergency medical service (EMS), the feasibility and effects of prehospital teleconsultation were investigated.
METHODOLOGY/PRINCIPAL FINDINGS: Teleconsultation enabling audio communication, real-time video streaming, vital data and still picture transmission was conducted between an ambulance and a teleconsultation center. Pre-notification of the hospital was carried out with a 14-item stroke history checklist via e-mail-to-fax. Beside technical assessments possible influences on prehospital and initial in-hospital time intervals, prehospital diagnostic accuracy and the transfer of stroke specific data were investigated by comparing telemedically assisted prehospital care (telemedicine group) with local regular EMS care (control group). All prehospital stroke patients over a 5-month period were included during weekdays (7.30 a.m.-4.00 p.m.). In 3 of 18 missions partial dropouts of the system occurred; neurological co-evaluation via video transmission was conducted in 12 cases. The stroke checklist was transmitted in 14 cases (78%). Telemedicine group (n = 18) vs. control group (n = 47): Prehospital time intervals were comparable, but in both groups the door to brain imaging times were longer than recommended (median 59.5 vs. 57.5 min, p = 0.6447). The prehospital stroke diagnosis was confirmed in 61% vs. 67%, p = 0.8451. Medians of 14 (IQR 9) vs. 5 (IQR 2) stroke specific items were transferred in written form to the in-hospital setting, p<0.0001. In 3 of 10 vs. 5 of 27 patients with cerebral ischemia thrombolytics were administered, p = 0.655.
Teleconsultation was feasible but technical performance and reliability have to be improved. The approach led to better stroke specific information; however, a superiority over regular EMS care was not found and in-hospital time intervals were unacceptably long in both groups. The feasibility of prehospital tele-stroke consultation has future potential to improve emergency care especially when no highly trained personnel are on-scene.
International Standard Randomised Controlled Trial Number Register (ISRCTN) ISRCTN83270177.
医院间远程会诊可改善卒中治疗。为将该理念应用于急救医疗服务(EMS),我们对院前远程会诊的可行性和效果进行了研究。
方法/主要发现:通过救护车与远程会诊中心之间的音频通信、实时视频流、生命数据和静态图像传输,实现远程会诊。通过电子邮件至传真的 14 项卒中病史检查表进行医院前预先通知。通过比较远程医疗辅助院前护理(远程医疗组)与当地常规 EMS 护理(对照组),调查了对院前和初始院内时间间隔、院前诊断准确性和卒中特定数据传输的可能影响。在 5 个月的工作日期间(上午 7.30 至下午 4.00),纳入所有院前卒中患者。在 18 次任务中,有 3 次系统出现部分中断;通过视频传输进行了 12 次神经学共同评估。在 14 次任务中(78%)传输了卒中检查表。远程医疗组(n=18)与对照组(n=47):院前时间间隔相当,但在两组中,门到脑成像时间均长于推荐时间(中位数分别为 59.5 和 57.5 分钟,p=0.6447)。院前卒中诊断在 61%和 67%的患者中得到证实,p=0.8451。以书面形式传输到院内环境的 14 项(IQR 9)与 5 项(IQR 2)卒中特定项目的中位数,p<0.0001。在 10 名患者中的 3 名与 27 名患者中的 5 名发生脑缺血时使用了溶栓药物,p=0.655。
远程会诊是可行的,但技术性能和可靠性有待提高。该方法提供了更好的卒中特定信息;然而,与常规 EMS 护理相比,并未发现优势,且两组的院内时间间隔均过长。院前远程卒中会诊的可行性具有改善急救护理的未来潜力,尤其是在现场没有高技能人员的情况下。
国际标准随机对照试验注册号注册(ISRCTN)ISRCTN83270177。