Alghamdi Ibrahim, Brunton Lisa, Ashton Christopher, Jenkins David A, Parry-Jones Adrian R
Division of Cardiovascular Sciences, The University of Manchester, Manchester, UK
Department of Emergency Medical Services, College of Applied Medical Sciences, Khamis Mushait Campus, King Khalid University, Abha, Asir, Saudi Arabia.
BMJ Open Qual. 2025 Jan 2;14(1):e002954. doi: 10.1136/bmjoq-2024-002954.
Stroke is a leading cause of mortality and morbidity, demanding prompt and accurate identification. However, prehospital diagnosis is challenging, with up to 50% of suspected strokes having other diagnoses. A prehospital video triage (PHVT) system was piloted in Greater Manchester to improve prehospital diagnostic accuracy and appropriate conveyance decisions.
A service evaluation of a PHVT pilot was conducted to assess PHVT efficacy and identify facilitators and barriers. The pilot (October-December 2022) was a collaboration between the North West Ambulance Service, Greater Manchester Neurorehabilitation and Integrated Stroke Delivery Network and stroke clinicians at Salford Royal Hospital. The service evaluation was mixed methods, including qualitative semistructured interviews with stroke clinicians, paramedics and patients (and/or caregivers). Interviews were analysed using a thematic approach.
Out of 46 PHVT calls during the pilot, eight (18%) were diverted to local emergency department, 1 (2%) was left at their usual residence and 37 (80%) were transported to Salford Royal Hospital. Final diagnosis for PHVT patients was stroke in 15 (33%) of cases, non-stroke in 20 (43%) and transient ischaemic attack in 11 (24%).Patients/caregivers found PHVT beneficial in directing them to appropriate hospitals and streamlining admission and treatment. However, some reported delays as a result. Clinicians expressed mixed opinions regarding PHVT's utility. Paramedics found PHVT improved confidence in managing stroke patients. Hospital clinicians believed it provided valuable prearrival patient information, enhancing preparation. Others found PHVT less effective due to on-scene delays, challenges conducting comprehensive assessments over video and inability to identify all non-stroke cases.
PHVT was viewed favourably by most patients for enhancing the care quality. Paramedics and hospital clinicians acknowledge PHVT's support in making appropriate conveyance decisions and improving the preparation process before the patient's arrival. Participants, however, suggested prearrival registration, 24-hour availability and clinicians' buy-in for a more effective future rollout.
中风是导致死亡和发病的主要原因,需要迅速而准确的识别。然而,院前诊断具有挑战性,高达50%的疑似中风患者有其他诊断结果。大曼彻斯特地区试点了一个院前视频分诊(PHVT)系统,以提高院前诊断准确性和做出合适的转运决策。
对PHVT试点进行了服务评估,以评估PHVT的效果,并确定促进因素和障碍。该试点(2022年10月至12月)是西北救护车服务公司、大曼彻斯特神经康复与综合中风服务网络以及索尔福德皇家医院的中风临床医生之间的合作。该服务评估采用了混合方法,包括对中风临床医生、护理人员以及患者(和/或护理人员)进行定性半结构化访谈。访谈采用主题分析法进行分析。
在试点期间的46次PHVT呼叫中,8次(18%)被转至当地急诊科,1次(2%)留在其常住地,37次(80%)被送往索尔福德皇家医院。PHVT患者的最终诊断结果为中风的有15例(33%),非中风的有20例(43%),短暂性脑缺血发作的有11例(24%)。患者/护理人员发现PHVT有助于引导他们前往合适的医院,并简化入院和治疗流程。然而,一些人报告称因此出现了延误。临床医生对PHVT的效用看法不一。护理人员发现PHVT提高了管理中风患者的信心。医院临床医生认为它提供了有价值的患者到达前信息,增强了准备工作。其他人则认为由于现场延误、通过视频进行全面评估存在挑战以及无法识别所有非中风病例,PHVT效果较差。
大多数患者对PHVT给予好评,认为它提高了护理质量。护理人员和医院临床医生认可PHVT在做出合适的转运决策以及改善患者到达前的准备过程方面的支持。然而,参与者建议进行到达前登记、提供24小时服务以及临床医生的支持,以便未来更有效地推广。