Hadassah-Hebrew University Medical Center, Jerusalem, Israel.
Clin Exp Rheumatol. 2012 Sep-Oct;30(5):735-40. Epub 2012 Oct 17.
The best treatment for patients with Behçet's disease (BD) with major vessel thrombosis has not been fully determined. Our objective was to raise this therapeutic dilemma and to call for controlled studies to help establish guidelines to address this problem.
Three patients with BD and major vessel thrombosis whom we recently encountered are described. Their cases were presented to rheumatologists from Turkey, Israel and the USA. The physicians were asked about the kind of treatment they would give each patient at diagnosis of thrombosis and if they chose to give anticoagulation and for long.
Fifty-five Turkish, 33 Israeli and 25 American rheumatologists responded to the questionnaire. More than 87% of the Israeli and American rheumatologists would give anticoagulation at the time of diagnosis for the cases of venous thrombosis compared with only 40-44% of the Turkish physicians. In these cases 56% of the American and 45% of the Israeli rheumatologists would give warfarin for life compared with only 5-18% of the Turkish physicians. Regarding a case with intra-cardiac thrombus, 96% of American, 94% of Israeli, and 60% of Turkish rheumatologists would start anticoagulation at diagnosis while 70%, 39% and 33%, respectively would give this treatment for life.
The therapeutic approach towards thrombosis in Behçet's disease differs significantly among rheumatologists from different countries. The different prevalence of the disease in these countries may explain this difference. A randomised controlled prospective trial is needed in order to determine the exact role of anticoagulant treatment in BD.
对于伴有大血管血栓形成的白塞病(BD)患者,最佳治疗方法尚未完全确定。我们的目的是提出这一治疗难题,并呼吁开展对照研究,以帮助制定解决这一问题的指南。
描述了我们最近遇到的 3 例伴有大血管血栓形成的 BD 患者。他们的病例被提交给了来自土耳其、以色列和美国的风湿病学家。我们询问了每位医生在血栓形成时会给患者何种治疗,如果选择抗凝治疗,会选择多长时间。
55 名土耳其、33 名以色列和 25 名美国风湿病学家对问卷做出了回应。与土耳其医生相比,超过 87%的以色列和美国风湿病学家会在诊断静脉血栓形成时给予抗凝治疗,而只有 40-44%的土耳其医生会这样做。在这些情况下,56%的美国和 45%的以色列风湿病学家会终生给予华法林治疗,而只有 5-18%的土耳其医生会这样做。对于患有心内血栓的病例,96%的美国、94%的以色列和 60%的土耳其风湿病学家会在诊断时开始抗凝治疗,而分别有 70%、39%和 33%的医生会终生给予这种治疗。
不同国家的风湿病学家对白塞病血栓形成的治疗方法存在显著差异。这些国家疾病的不同流行率可能解释了这一差异。需要进行随机对照前瞻性试验,以确定抗凝治疗在 BD 中的确切作用。