John Angela E, Dobson Lauren A, Thomas Lauren E, Mervis Carolyn B
Department of Psychological and Brain Sciences, University of Louisville Louisville, KY, USA.
Front Psychol. 2012 Jun 18;3:199. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2012.00199. eCollection 2012.
Prior research has indicated that pragmatics is an area of particular weakness for individuals with Williams syndrome (WS). To further address this aspect of the WS social phenotype, we used an individual differences approach to consider both cross-sectional and longitudinal relations among different pragmatic abilities for 14 children with WS, taking into account individual differences in non-verbal reasoning abilities. We also considered the relations between pragmatic abilities and expressive vocabulary ability. Participants were tested at two time points: as 4-year-olds during a 30-min play session with their mothers (Time 1) and an average of 5.87 years later during a one-on-one conversation with a familiar researcher (Time 2). Children's intellectual and expressive vocabulary abilities were assessed at both time points. Results indicated that the ability to verbally contribute information beyond what was required in response to a question (ExtendQ) was significantly related to the ability to verbally contribute new information in the absence of a question (ExtendS) both at age 4 years and during primary school. At age 4, both the ability to pair verbalizations with eye contact in triadic interactions (secondary intersubjectivity) and expressive vocabulary ability were related to both ExtendQ and ExtendS. Finally, both ExtendQ and the ability to pair verbalizations with eye contact (intersubjectivity) at age 4 years predicted ExtendQ at age 9-12 years. The theoretical implications of our findings and the importance of early pragmatic language intervention for children who have WS are discussed.
先前的研究表明,语用学是威廉姆斯综合征(WS)患者特别薄弱的一个领域。为了进一步探究WS社会表型的这一方面,我们采用个体差异方法,考虑了14名WS儿童不同语用能力之间的横断面和纵向关系,并将非言语推理能力的个体差异纳入考量。我们还考察了语用能力与表达性词汇能力之间的关系。参与者在两个时间点接受测试:4岁时与母亲进行30分钟的玩耍互动(时间1),以及平均5.87年后与熟悉的研究人员进行一对一谈话时(时间2)。在两个时间点都对儿童的智力和表达性词汇能力进行了评估。结果表明,在4岁以及小学阶段,在回答问题时口头提供超出要求信息的能力(扩展问题能力)与在没有问题时口头提供新信息的能力(扩展陈述能力)显著相关。4岁时,在三元互动中将言语表达与眼神交流配对的能力(二级主体间性)和表达性词汇能力都与扩展问题能力和扩展陈述能力相关。最后,4岁时的扩展问题能力以及将言语表达与眼神交流配对的能力(主体间性)预测了9至12岁时的扩展问题能力。我们讨论了研究结果的理论意义以及早期语用语言干预对WS儿童的重要性。