Department of Preventive Medicine & Epidemiology, Loyola University Chicago, Maywood, Illinois, United States of America.
PLoS One. 2012;7(6):e39795. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0039795. Epub 2012 Jun 29.
Recent studies suggest that obesity may be "contagious" between individuals in social networks. Social contagion (influence), however, may not be identifiable using traditional statistical approaches because they cannot distinguish contagion from homophily (the propensity for individuals to select friends who are similar to themselves) or from shared environmental influences. In this paper, we apply the stochastic actor-based model (SABM) framework developed by Snijders and colleagues to data on adolescent body mass index (BMI), screen time, and playing active sports. Our primary hypothesis was that social influences on adolescent body size and related behaviors are independent of friend selection. Employing the SABM, we simultaneously modeled network dynamics (friendship selection based on homophily and structural characteristics of the network) and social influence. We focused on the 2 largest schools in the National Longitudinal Study of Adolescent Health (Add Health) and held the school environment constant by examining the 2 school networks separately (N = 624 and 1151). Results show support in both schools for homophily on BMI, but also for social influence on BMI. There was no evidence of homophily on screen time in either school, while only one of the schools showed homophily on playing active sports. There was, however, evidence of social influence on screen time in one of the schools, and playing active sports in both schools. These results suggest that both homophily and social influence are important in understanding patterns of adolescent obesity. Intervention efforts should take into consideration peers' influence on one another, rather than treating "high risk" adolescents in isolation.
最近的研究表明,肥胖在社交网络中的个体之间可能具有“传染性”。然而,社交传染(影响)可能无法通过传统的统计方法来识别,因为它们无法区分传染与同质性(个体选择与自己相似的朋友的倾向)或共同的环境影响。在本文中,我们应用 Snijders 及其同事开发的随机主体模型(SABM)框架来分析青少年体重指数(BMI)、屏幕时间和积极运动的数据。我们的主要假设是,社交对青少年体型和相关行为的影响独立于朋友选择。我们运用 SABM 同时模拟了网络动态(基于同质性和网络结构特征的友谊选择)和社会影响。我们专注于国家青少年健康纵向研究(Add Health)中最大的 2 所学校,并通过分别检查这 2 个学校网络来保持学校环境不变(N=624 和 1151)。结果在这两所学校都支持 BMI 上的同质性,但也支持 BMI 上的社会影响。两所学校都没有证据表明屏幕时间上存在同质性,而只有一所学校在积极运动上存在同质性。然而,一所学校的屏幕时间存在社会影响,两所学校的积极运动都存在社会影响。这些结果表明,同质性和社会影响在理解青少年肥胖模式方面都很重要。干预措施应该考虑到同伴之间的相互影响,而不是孤立地对待“高风险”青少年。