Department of Otorhinolaryngology, Seoul National University College of Medicine, Seoul, South Korea.
Eur Arch Otorhinolaryngol. 2013 Jan;270(1):339-44. doi: 10.1007/s00405-012-2098-0. Epub 2012 Jul 7.
The aim of this study was to compare coblation and diathermy techniques with respect to secondary post-tonsillectomy hemorrhage (PTH). A total of 1,397 children underwent tonsillectomies with or without adenoidectomy by a single surgeon in a single center from June 2005 through December 2011. A diathermy tonsillectomy was performed on 315 patients for the first 2 years, while a coblation tonsillectomy was performed on 1,082 for the next 5 years. All patients were followed-up within 28 days of surgery by the same surgeon. The characteristics of primary and secondary PTH were analyzed with a retrospective chart review. Primary PTH did not occur in both surgical technique groups. Secondary PTH occurred in 9 patients (2.9 %) in the diathermy group and in 30 patients (2.8 %) in the coblation group. The secondary PTH rates were 1.2, 2.5, 3.8, 3.1 and 4.5 % in the first, second, third, fourth and fifth years after employment of the coblation tonsillectomy, respectively (P = 0.243). Sex, age, tonsil size and severity of tonsillar embedding were not significant factors for PTH. The coblation technique was associated more with late secondary PTH than diathermy technique (odds ratio 9.14, P = 0.049). Analysis of the time of onset of PTH showed that secondary PTH occurred most commonly between 6 p.m. and 6 a.m. In summary, coblation technique has similar secondary PTH rate with diathermy technique although it has increased late secondary PTH rate in children. Coblation technique can be a good alternative to the diathermy technique.
本研究旨在比较电凝和射频技术在扁桃体切除术后继发性出血(PTH)方面的差异。2005 年 6 月至 2011 年 12 月,一名外科医生在一个中心对 1397 例儿童进行了扁桃体切除术(或联合腺样体切除术)。在前 2 年,315 例患者采用电凝技术进行扁桃体切除术,接下来的 5 年,1082 例患者采用射频技术进行扁桃体切除术。所有患者均由同一名外科医生在术后 28 天内进行随访。通过回顾性图表审查分析原发性和继发性 PTH 的特征。两种手术技术组均未发生原发性 PTH。电凝组有 9 例(2.9%)和射频组有 30 例(2.8%)发生继发性 PTH。在采用射频扁桃体切除术的第 1、2、3、4 和 5 年后,继发性 PTH 的发生率分别为 1.2%、2.5%、3.8%、3.1%和 4.5%(P = 0.243)。性别、年龄、扁桃体大小和扁桃体嵌入严重程度不是 PTH 的显著因素。与电凝技术相比,射频技术与迟发性继发性 PTH 更相关(比值比 9.14,P = 0.049)。对 PTH 发病时间的分析表明,继发性 PTH 最常发生在下午 6 点至上午 6 点之间。总之,尽管射频技术会增加儿童迟发性继发性 PTH 的发生率,但它与电凝技术具有相似的继发性 PTH 发生率。射频技术可以作为电凝技术的良好替代方法。