Department of Orthopedic Surgery, Gunma Spine Center (Harunaso Hospital), 878-1 Kamitoyooka, Takasaki, Gunma 370-0871, Japan.
Eur Spine J. 2012 Dec;21(12):2506-11. doi: 10.1007/s00586-012-2448-z. Epub 2012 Jul 27.
Mutilating-type rheumatoid arthritis, the most aggressive type of rheumatoid arthritis, is frequently associated with destructive cervical involvement, both at the high-cervical and subaxial levels, causing significant neurological deficit, and their natural course of the disease and the survival are discouraging. For such cases, we have been actively performing occipito-thoracic fusion since 1991. Although medical treatment for rheumatoid patients has represented a marked improvement, it could not treat all of these patients because of several reasons. Therefore, it is still important to evaluate the past treatment results.
We investigated the neurological improvement and prognosis in 51 mutilating-type rheumatoid arthritis patients who underwent occipito-thoracic fusion between 1991 and 2010. The neurological status was evaluated using modified Ranawat classification; class IIIB was subdivided into IIIBa (able to sit upright) and IIIBb (bedridden).
The preoperative neurologic status was IIIBa in 19 patients and IIIBb in 17 patients. 15 of the 19 patients with class IIIBa improved to being able to walk (79 %), whereas only 3 of the 17 patients with class IIIBb improved to being able to walk (18 %) after surgery. Of the 51 patients, 28 died during follow-up; the mean age at death was 67.2 years. The postoperative 5- and 10-year survival rates were 60.3 and 26.4 %, respectively.
The neurological improvement and prognosis after surgery was poorer in class IIIBb patients than in the other patient groups. Occipito-thoracic fusion can improve the neurological symptoms and prognosis. However, early surgical intervention is recommended, before a patient becomes bedridden (class IIIBb).
致残型类风湿关节炎是最具侵袭性的类风湿关节炎类型,常伴有破坏性颈椎受累,包括高颈椎和下颈椎,导致严重的神经功能缺损,其自然病程和生存状况令人沮丧。对于此类病例,我们自 1991 年以来一直积极开展枕胸融合术。虽然类风湿患者的药物治疗取得了显著进展,但由于多种原因,并非所有患者都能从中获益。因此,评估既往治疗结果仍然很重要。
我们调查了 1991 年至 2010 年间接受枕胸融合术的 51 例致残型类风湿关节炎患者的神经改善和预后情况。神经状态采用改良 Ranawat 分级进行评估;IIIb 级进一步分为 IIIBa(能坐直)和 IIIBb(卧床不起)。
术前神经状态为 IIIBa 的患者有 19 例,IIIBb 的患者有 17 例。19 例 IIIBa 级患者中有 15 例改善到能够行走(79%),而 17 例 IIIBb 级患者中仅有 3 例改善到能够行走(18%)。51 例患者中,28 例在随访期间死亡;死亡时的平均年龄为 67.2 岁。术后 5 年和 10 年的生存率分别为 60.3%和 26.4%。
与其他患者群体相比,IIIBb 级患者术后神经改善和预后较差。枕胸融合术可以改善神经症状和预后。然而,建议在患者卧床不起(IIIBb 级)之前尽早进行手术干预。