Centre for Infectious Diseases and Microbiology Laboratory Services, Institute of Clinical Pathology and Medical Research, Westmead Hospital, NSW, Australia.
J Clin Microbiol. 2012 Nov;50(11):3478-84. doi: 10.1128/JCM.01311-12. Epub 2012 Aug 8.
While 16S rRNA sequence-based identification of Nocardia species has become the gold standard, it is not without its limitations. We evaluated a novel approach encompassing the amplification of the Nocardia 16S-23S rRNA intergenic spacer (IGS) region followed by fragment analysis by capillary gel electrophoresis (CGE) of the amplified product for species identification of Nocardia. One hundred forty-five Nocardia isolates (19 species) and four non-Nocardia aerobic actinomycetes were studied. Reproducibility testing was performed in a subset (21%) of isolates. Ninety-five different electropherograms were identified, with heterogeneity within species being a general observation. Among common Nocardia species (e.g., Nocardia cyriacigeorgica, N. nova, N. farcinica), 2 or 3 dominant electropherogram subgroups were typical. While only a minority (8/19; 42%) of the different Nocardia species contained isolates displaying unique fragment sizes that were predictive of a particular species, virtually all isolates (142/145; 98%) could be assigned to the correct species using IGS-CGE typing based on the number and size of amplified fragments. The median number of fragments for each isolate was 2 (range, 1 to 5) with only a minority (17%) having a single fragment detected. The majority (93%) of amplified fragments were between 408 and 461 bp. The technique was also non-operator dependent, highly reproducible, and quicker and less expensive than 16S sequencing. In summary, PCR-based IGS-CGE typing is relatively simple, accurate, reproducible, and cost-effective and offers a potential alternative to 16S rRNA sequencing for identifying and subtyping Nocardia isolates.
虽然基于 16S rRNA 序列的诺卡氏菌种鉴定已成为金标准,但它并非没有局限性。我们评估了一种新方法,包括扩增诺卡氏菌 16S-23S rRNA 基因间隔区(IGS),然后对扩增产物进行毛细管凝胶电泳(CGE)片段分析,以鉴定诺卡氏菌的种。我们研究了 145 株诺卡氏菌分离株(19 个种)和 4 株非诺卡氏需氧放线菌。在分离株的一个亚组(21%)中进行了重复性测试。鉴定出了 95 种不同的电泳图谱,种内存在异质性是普遍现象。在常见的诺卡氏菌(如 Nocardia cyriacigeorgica、Nocardia nova 和 Nocardia farcinica)中,通常存在 2 或 3 个主要的电泳图谱亚群。虽然只有少数(8/19;42%)不同的诺卡氏菌种包含显示特定种预测性独特片段大小的分离株,但实际上,几乎所有的分离株(142/145;98%)都可以通过 IGS-CGE 分型根据扩增片段的数量和大小分配到正确的种。每个分离株的片段中位数为 2(范围为 1 至 5),只有少数(17%)检测到单个片段。大多数扩增片段(93%)在 408 至 461 bp 之间。该技术也不依赖于操作人员,具有高度可重复性,比 16S 测序更快、更便宜。总之,基于 PCR 的 IGS-CGE 分型相对简单、准确、可重复、经济有效,为鉴定和亚分型诺卡氏菌分离株提供了一种替代 16S rRNA 测序的潜在方法。