Wulff Helge E, Melin A, Waaddegaard M, Kanstrup I L
Department of Exercise and Sport Sciences, University of Copenhagen, Copenhagen, Denmark.
J Sports Med Phys Fitness. 2012 Oct;52(5):489-500.
Female endurance athletes suffering from low energy availability and reproductive hormonal disorders are at risk of low BMD. Muscle forces acting on bone may have a reverse site-specific effect. Therefore we wanted to test how BMD in female elite triathletes was associated to isokinetic peak torque (IPT) and reproductive hormone concentrations (RHC). A possible effect of oral contraceptives (OCON's) is taken into consideration.
Eight female elite triathletes (training 8-24 hrs/wk) and seven sedentary controls, age 21-37 years, participated. Total body and regional BMD (g.cm-2) were measured by DXA. IPT were measured during knee extension, and trunk extension and flexion (Nm). Serum RHC and biochemical bone markers were evaluated. Energy balance was estimated from 7-days training-and weighed food records.
Despite a high training volume, BMD in triathletes was not higher than in controls. In triathletes trunk flexion IPT, but not RHC, was a strong predictor of BMD in both total body and femur (0.70<r<0.86, P<0.05). RHC did not differ between triathletes and controls, but in OCON-users RHC (in controls also BMD) seemed lower than in non-users. Energy intake in triathletes corresponded to 65-111% of energy expenditure.
The association between trunk flexion IPT and BMD in triathletes supports the theory that muscle forces are important osteogenic factors. The findings of no correlation between RHC and BMD, but a tendency to a negative effect of low RHC only in OCON-controls, might indicate that in female athletes muscle forces acting on bone potentially counteract a negative effect of reproductive hormonal disorders on BMD.
患有能量供应不足和生殖激素紊乱的女性耐力运动员存在骨密度低的风险。作用于骨骼的肌肉力量可能具有反向的部位特异性效应。因此,我们想测试女性精英铁人三项运动员的骨密度与等速峰值扭矩(IPT)和生殖激素浓度(RHC)之间的关系。同时考虑口服避孕药(OCON)的可能影响。
招募了8名年龄在21 - 37岁的女性精英铁人三项运动员(每周训练8 - 24小时)和7名久坐不动的对照者。通过双能X线吸收法(DXA)测量全身和局部骨密度(g.cm-2)。在膝关节伸展、躯干伸展和屈曲过程中测量IPT(Nm)。评估血清RHC和生化骨标志物。根据7天的训练和称重食物记录估算能量平衡。
尽管铁人三项运动员的训练量很大,但其骨密度并不高于对照组。在铁人三项运动员中,躯干屈曲IPT而非RHC是全身和股骨骨密度的强预测指标(0.70 < r < 0.86,P < 0.05)。铁人三项运动员和对照组之间的RHC没有差异,但在服用OCON的人群中,RHC(对照组中的骨密度也是如此)似乎低于未使用者。铁人三项运动员的能量摄入相当于能量消耗的65 - 111%。
铁人三项运动员躯干屈曲IPT与骨密度之间的关联支持了肌肉力量是重要成骨因素的理论。RHC与骨密度之间无相关性,但仅在服用OCON的对照组中有低RHC产生负面影响的趋势,这可能表明在女性运动员中,作用于骨骼的肌肉力量可能抵消了生殖激素紊乱对骨密度的负面影响。