Gloucestershire Oncology Centre, Cheltenham General Hospital, Cheltenham, UK.
Clin Oncol (R Coll Radiol). 2012 Dec;24(10):e143-8. doi: 10.1016/j.clon.2012.08.005. Epub 2012 Sep 13.
To seek the views of consultants appointed less than 2 years ago on the appropriateness of their training in fitting them to carry out their present posts, the FRCR examination, experience of research and the prevalence and value of out of programme experience and acting up as a consultant.
All the consultants identified from the Royal College of Radiologists' database as having been appointed to a consultant post in the last 2 years were emailed inviting them to take part in a web-based survey.
The response rate was 60% (32 of 53 consultants). Ninety-four per cent agreed or strongly agreed that training had equipped them for clinical work as a consultant, but only 44% agreed or strongly agreed that training had equipped them to fulfil the management roles. Free text answers stressed the importance of management skills, getting involved with trial set-up and producing publications early in their career. Ninety-four per cent agreed or strongly agreed that they had adequate opportunity to develop skills in systemic therapy and radiotherapy planning, but only 56% thought this was the case for intensity-modulated radiotherapy and image-guided radiotherapy. Although 87% agreed or strongly agreed they had sufficient opportunity to develop teaching skills, this was only the case in 62% with regard to research skills. They published a median number of three papers in peer-reviewed journals. Twenty-five per cent of respondents studied for research degrees; 69% of consultants had undertaken out of programme experience and 50% had acted up as a consultant and these were generally found to be valuable experiences. There was strong support for the FRCR examination.
Consultants appointed in the last 2 years are generally satisfied with their training. Training in intensity-modulated radiotherapy and image-guided radiotherapy should be improved and the advanced specialist training requires reviewing to better fit consultants for subspecialisation, management and research.
了解在过去 2 年内新任命的顾问对其培训的看法,以确定其是否适合当前的职位、通过 FRCR 考试、开展研究工作以及是否有计划外的经验和代理顾问的经历。
从皇家放射学院的数据库中确定所有在过去 2 年内被任命为顾问职位的顾问,并通过电子邮件邀请他们参加基于网络的调查。
回应率为 60%(32 名顾问中的 32 名)。94%的人同意或强烈同意培训使他们能够胜任顾问的临床工作,但只有 44%的人同意或强烈同意培训使他们能够履行管理职责。自由文本回答强调了管理技能的重要性,尽早参与试验设计和发表论文。94%的人同意或强烈同意他们有足够的机会发展系统治疗和放射治疗计划方面的技能,但只有 56%的人认为这适用于强度调制放射治疗和图像引导放射治疗。尽管 87%的人同意或强烈同意他们有足够的机会发展教学技能,但只有 62%的人认为他们有足够的机会发展研究技能。他们在同行评议的期刊上发表了 3 篇论文的中位数。25%的受访者攻读研究学位;69%的顾问有计划外的经验,50%的人代理过顾问,这些经验通常被认为是有价值的。他们强烈支持 FRCR 考试。
在过去 2 年内任命的顾问对他们的培训总体上感到满意。应改进强度调制放射治疗和图像引导放射治疗方面的培训,并且需要对高级专科培训进行审查,以使顾问更好地适应专业化、管理和研究工作。