Kim Hun Jung, Kim Woochul
Department of Radiation Oncology, Inha University Hospital, Inha University School of Medicine, Incheon, Korea.
Radiat Oncol J. 2012 Jun;30(2):70-7. doi: 10.3857/roj.2012.30.2.70. Epub 2012 Jun 30.
To evaluate the patterns of tumor shape and to compare tumor volume derived from simple diameter-based ellipsoid measurement with that derived from tracing the entire tumor contour using region of interest (ROI)-based 3D volumetry with respect to the prediction outcome in cervical cancer patients treated with concurrent chemotherapy and radiotherapy.
Magnetic resonance imaging was performed in 98 patients with cervical cancer (stage IB-IIIB). The tumor shape was classified into two categories: ellipsoid and non-ellipsoid shape. ROI-based volumetry was derived from each magnetic resonance slice on the work station. For the diameter-based surrogate "ellipsoid volume," the three orthogonal diameters were measured to calculate volume as an ellipsoid.
The more than half of tumor (55.1%) had a non-ellipsoid configuration. The predictions for outcome were consistent between two volume groups, with overall survival of 93.6% and 87.7% for small tumor (<20 mL), 62.9% and 69.1% for intermediate-size tumor (20-39 mL), and 14.5% and 16.7% for large tumors (≥40 mL) using ROI and diameter based measurement, respectively. Disease-free survival was 93.8% and 90.6% for small tumor, 54.3% and 62.7% for intermediate-size tumor, and 13.7% and 10.3% for large tumor using ROI and diameter based method, respectively. Differences in outcome between size groups were statistically significant, and the differences in outcome predicted by the tumor volume by two different methods.
Our data suggested that large numbers of cervical cancers are not ellipsoid. However, simple diameter-based tumor volume measurement appears to be useful in comparison with ROI-based volumetry for predicting outcome in cervical cancer patients.
评估肿瘤形状模式,并比较基于简单直径的椭球体测量法得出的肿瘤体积与使用基于感兴趣区域(ROI)的三维容积测量法描绘整个肿瘤轮廓得出的肿瘤体积,以探讨其对接受同步放化疗的宫颈癌患者预后的预测价值。
对98例宫颈癌患者(IB-IIIB期)进行磁共振成像检查。肿瘤形状分为两类:椭球体形状和非椭球体形状。基于ROI的容积测量法是在工作站上从每个磁共振切片得出的。对于基于直径的替代“椭球体体积”,测量三个相互垂直的直径以计算椭球体体积。
超过一半的肿瘤(55.1%)为非椭球体形态。两个体积组对预后的预测结果一致,基于ROI测量法和基于直径测量法得出的小肿瘤(<20 mL)的总生存率分别为93.6%和87.7%,中等大小肿瘤(20-39 mL)分别为62.9%和69.1%,大肿瘤(≥40 mL)分别为14.5%和16.7%。基于ROI测量法和基于直径测量法得出的小肿瘤无病生存率分别为93.8%和90.6%,中等大小肿瘤分别为54.3%和62.