Westerlund Michael, Hadlaczky Gergo, Wasserman Danuta
Department of Learning, Informatics, Management and Ethics, Karolinska Institutet, Stockholm, Sweden.
J Med Internet Res. 2012 Sep 26;14(5):e122. doi: 10.2196/jmir.1979.
Suicide is one of the major causes of death in the world, leading to approximately 1 million deaths per year. While much of what is said about suicide and its causes is still taboo in most contemporary societies and cultures, internet websites and discussion forums have become an important and controversial source of information on the subject. A great deal of ambivalence is discernible as to whether online communication about suicide primarily should be seen as an opportunity or a serious threat.
To investigate how the subject of suicide is represented on the Internet, based on hits generated by the search engine Google.
In an exploratory design, Google search results on the target word "suicide", for the years 2005, 2009, and 2012 respectively, were systematically analyzed and compared.
The study shows that web pages of institutional origin on the subject predominate, that the content provided by these institutions concerns primarily research and prevention, and that the form of communication used by these senders is almost exclusively monological. However, besides these institutional pages there are a substantial number of private senders and pages, often anti-medical and against treatment of depression and other mental problems, characterized by dialogue, confessions and narratives, and to a higher degree, an alternative pro-suicide stance.
To counteract the influence of anti-medical and pro-suicide information, the role of the Internet should be discussed with the patient in clinical practice. Dialogical and confessional communications provide an opportunity for the clinician to gain a deeper perspective into perceptions of patients, regarding both their afflictions and the role of medical treatment in their lives.
自杀是全球主要死因之一,每年导致约100万人死亡。尽管在大多数当代社会和文化中,许多关于自杀及其原因的话题仍是禁忌,但互联网网站和讨论论坛已成为该主题重要且具争议性的信息来源。关于自杀的在线交流究竟应主要被视为一种机遇还是严重威胁,存在诸多矛盾观点。
基于谷歌搜索引擎的搜索结果,调查互联网上自杀主题的呈现方式。
采用探索性设计,系统分析并比较了谷歌在2005年、2009年和2012年分别针对目标词“自杀”的搜索结果。
研究表明,该主题的机构来源网页占主导,这些机构提供的内容主要涉及研究和预防,且这些信息发布者使用的交流形式几乎全是单向的。然而,除了这些机构网页外,还有大量私人信息发布者和网页,它们往往反对医学以及抑郁症和其他心理问题的治疗,其特点是对话、忏悔和叙述,且在更高程度上持支持自杀的立场。
为抵消反医学和支持自杀信息的影响,临床实践中应与患者讨论互联网的作用。对话式和忏悔式交流为临床医生提供了一个机会,使其能更深入地了解患者对自身痛苦以及医疗在其生活中作用的看法。