AbuRahma A F, Robinson P A
Vascular Laboratory, West Virginia University Health Sciences Center, Charleston.
Am Surg. 1990 Feb;56(2):108-13.
Three hundred asymptomatic carotid bruits (ACB) were followed prospectively, clinically, and by duplex ultrasound with Gee/ocular plethysmography (OPG) for a period ranging from one to 72 months (mean, 32 months). All patients underwent baseline duplex/OPG, which was repeated every six months until the endpoint, transient ischemic attack (TIA) or cerebrovascular accident (CVA). One hundred seven had arteriograms. Five classes were identified: class I (normal): 96/300 (32%), 79 of these were followed and one had TIA (1/79, 1.3%); class II (less than 50% stenosis): 118/300 (39%), 105 of these were followed, three had TIA, and one had CVA (4/105, 3.8%); class III (50-60% stenosis): 25/300 (8%), 21 were followed, one had TIA (1/21, 4.7%); class IV (more than 60% stenosis with negative OPG): 39/300 (13%), 34 were followed, three had TIA, and one had CVA (4/34, 11.7%); and class V (more than 60% stenosis with positive OPG): 22/300 (7%), 18 were followed, three had TIA, and one had CVA (4/18, 22.2%). Data was analyzed using chi-square with Yates correction. In conclusion, in ACB 32 per cent had no carotid stenosis and 39 per cent had minimal disease with minimal risk of TIA or stroke. Patients with the most severe stenoses (classes IV and V) had a statistically significantly higher likelihood of TIA or CVA occurring during the follow-up period. This last group (class V) would be ideal for prophylactic carotid endarterectomy.
对300例无症状性颈动脉杂音(ACB)患者进行了为期1至72个月(平均32个月)的前瞻性临床随访,并采用Gee/眼体积描记法(OPG)进行双功超声检查。所有患者均接受了基线双功/OPG检查,每6个月重复一次,直至达到终点,即短暂性脑缺血发作(TIA)或脑血管意外(CVA)。107例患者进行了动脉造影。共识别出五类:I类(正常):96/300(32%),其中79例接受随访,1例发生TIA(1/79,1.3%);II类(狭窄小于50%):118/300(39%),其中105例接受随访,3例发生TIA,1例发生CVA(4/105,3.8%);III类(狭窄50 - 60%):25/300(8%),21例接受随访,1例发生TIA(1/21,4.7%);IV类(狭窄大于60%且OPG阴性):39/300(13%),34例接受随访,3例发生TIA,1例发生CVA(4/34,11.7%);V类(狭窄大于60%且OPG阳性):22/300(7%),18例接受随访,3例发生TIA,1例发生CVA(4/18,22.2%)。采用Yates校正的卡方检验对数据进行分析。总之,在ACB患者中,32%无颈动脉狭窄,39%疾病轻微,发生TIA或中风的风险极小。狭窄最严重的患者(IV类和V类)在随访期间发生TIA或CVA的可能性在统计学上显著更高。最后一组(V类)是预防性颈动脉内膜切除术的理想对象。