Eckes Lena, Tsokos Michael, Herre Sieglinde, Gapert René, Hartwig Sven
Institute of Legal Medicine and Forensic Sciences, Charité-University Medicine Berlin, Berlin, Germany.
Forensic Sci Med Pathol. 2013 Jun;9(2):145-53. doi: 10.1007/s12024-012-9383-5. Epub 2012 Oct 12.
Diphenhydramine (DPH), an H1-antihistamine, is identified during postmortem toxicological analyses on a relatively rare but still regular basis. This study examines suicidal intoxications with DPH by analyzing blood and gastric content concentration levels. Twenty cases of DPH intoxications within a 10-year period (2000-2010) were discovered by screening the autopsy records of the Institute of Legal Medicine and Forensic Sciences (ILMFS) in Berlin, Germany. In four cases, DPH levels were lower than 1 μg/mL and hence were not considered likely to be responsible for causing death. In 11 cases, DPH played a role in the fatal episode, and five of these cases were monointoxications. Considering that more than 8,000 autopsies were performed by the ILMFS within the time period under examination, there is only one monointoxication case every 2 years, which makes it a rare occurrence. In two of these intoxications, DPH was only measured in toxic but not "lethal" concentrations in blood, with a concentration of 5 μg/mL being generally used as the cut off between categories according to forensic literature. This raises the question as to whether a strict boundary for a "lethal" blood concentration, as suggested in some literature, can be set and applied in any of these cases. This study shows that an individual interpretation of each case is of utmost importance for correct classification. A thorough toxicological analysis of peripheral venous blood and gastric content, as well as a detailed work-up of the death circumstances, are the basis of an exact interpretation of intoxications with DPH.
苯海拉明(DPH)是一种H1抗组胺药,在尸检毒理学分析中虽相对少见但仍时有发现。本研究通过分析血液和胃内容物浓度水平来检测苯海拉明导致的自杀性中毒情况。通过筛查德国柏林法律医学与法医学研究所(ILMFS)的尸检记录,发现了10年期间(2000 - 2010年)的20例苯海拉明中毒案例。其中4例,苯海拉明水平低于1μg/mL,因此被认为不太可能是致死原因。在11例中,苯海拉明在致命事件中起了作用,其中5例为单一药物中毒。考虑到在检查期间ILMFS进行了8000多次尸检,每两年仅有1例单一药物中毒案例,这实属罕见。在其中2例中毒案例中,仅在血液中检测到了有毒但并非“致死”浓度的苯海拉明,根据法医文献,血液浓度5μg/mL通常被用作区分不同类别之间的界限。这就引发了一个问题,即是否能像某些文献所建议的那样,设定一个“致死”血液浓度的严格界限并应用于所有这些案例。本研究表明,对每个案例进行单独解读对于正确分类至关重要。对外周静脉血和胃内容物进行全面的毒理学分析,以及对死亡情况进行详细调查,是准确解读苯海拉明中毒情况的基础。