Department of Orthopaedics, Xijing Hospital, The Fourth Military Medical University, 127 West Changle Rd, Xi'an, Shaanxi Province 710032, China.
Spine J. 2012 Dec;12(12):1093-102. doi: 10.1016/j.spinee.2012.10.022. Epub 2012 Dec 6.
Ossification of the posterior longitudinal ligament (OPLL) or ossification of the ligamentum flavum (OLF) is being increasingly recognized as a cause of thoracic myelopathy and is relatively common in the Japanese population and literature. However, no series of OPLL combined with OLF has been previously published. Many different surgical procedures have been used for the treatment of thoracic OPLL or OLF. However, the possibility of postoperative paraplegia remains a major risk, and consistent protocols and procedures for surgical treatment of thoracic OPLL combined with OLF have also not been established.
To compare the effect of thoracic myelopathy treatment and safety of posterior decompression with or without instrumented fusion and circumferential spinal cord decompression via a posterior approach in Chinese patients of OPLL combined with OLF at a single institution.
This retrospective clinical study of 31 cases was conducted to investigate the clinical outcomes of three kinds of surgical procedures for thoracic myelopathy caused by OPLL combined with OLF in Chinese population.
Procedure was performed in 31 patients.
Neurologic status was evaluated using the Japanese Orthopaedic Association (JOA) score and Hirabayashi recovery rate before and after surgery.
A total of 31 patients who underwent surgery for thoracic OPLL combined with OLF were classified into three groups: posterior decompression group (13 patients); circumferential decompression group (seven patients), which included four who underwent extirpation and the other three underwent the floating procedure; and posterior decompression and fusion group (11 patients), all of whom underwent laminectomy with posterior instrumented fusion. In each group, JOA score was used to evaluate thoracic myelopathy, and Hirabayashi recovery rate was calculated 1 year after surgery and at final examination.
Mean recovery rate at the final follow-up was 46.5% in the posterior decompression group, 65.1% in the circumferential decompression group, and 62.7% in the posterior decompression and fusion group. Postoperative paralysis occurred in three patients in the posterior decompression group, one in the circumferential decompression group, and one in the posterior decompression and fusion group. In the circumferential decompression group, leakage of cerebrospinal fluid occurred in four patients. Urinary tract infection occurred in two patients, and superficial wound disruption occurred in one patient. Late neurologic deterioration occurred in four patients in the posterior decompression group. There were no cases of postoperative paralysis or late neurologic deterioration in the posterior decompression and fusion group.
Thoracic OPLL combined with OLF is an uncommon cause of myelopathy in the Chinese population. It can present acutely after minor trauma. A considerable degree of neurologic recovery was obtained by posterior decompression with instrumented fusion, despite the anterior impingement of the spinal cord by the remaining OPLL. In addition, the rate of postoperative complications was low with this procedure. We consider that one-stage posterior decompression and instrumented fusion be selected for patients in whom the spinal cord is severely damaged before surgery and/or when circumferential decompression is associated with an increased risk.
后纵韧带骨化(OPLL)或黄韧带骨化(OLF)越来越被认为是胸段脊髓病的原因,在日本人群和文献中较为常见。然而,此前尚未有关于 OPLL 合并 OLF 的系列报道。许多不同的手术方法已被用于治疗胸段 OPLL 或 OLF。然而,术后截瘫的可能性仍然是一个主要的风险,对于胸段 OPLL 合并 OLF 的手术治疗也没有建立一致的方案和程序。
比较后路减压联合或不联合后路内固定融合术与后路全脊椎切除术治疗中国 OPLL 合并 OLF 患者胸段脊髓病的疗效和安全性。
这是一项回顾性临床研究,共纳入 31 例 OPLL 合并 OLF 患者,旨在探讨三种手术方法治疗中国人群胸段脊髓病的临床效果。
共纳入 31 例患者。
神经功能状态采用日本矫形协会(JOA)评分和 Hirabayashi 恢复率进行评估,分别在术前和术后进行评估。
后路减压组(13 例)、全脊椎切除术组(7 例,其中 4 例行整块切除,3 例行浮动术)和后路减压融合组(11 例)。后路减压组采用后路减压术,全脊椎切除术组采用后路全脊椎切除术,后路减压融合组采用后路减压联合内固定融合术。各组均采用 JOA 评分评估胸段脊髓病,计算术后 1 年及末次随访时的 Hirabayashi 恢复率。
后路减压组的平均末次随访时恢复率为 46.5%,全脊椎切除术组为 65.1%,后路减压融合组为 62.7%。后路减压组术后出现 3 例瘫痪,全脊椎切除术组出现 1 例瘫痪,后路减压融合组出现 1 例瘫痪。全脊椎切除术组中有 4 例发生脑脊液漏,2 例发生尿路感染,1 例发生浅表伤口破裂。后路减压组有 4 例患者出现术后神经功能恶化。后路减压融合组无术后瘫痪或术后神经功能恶化病例。
胸段 OPLL 合并 OLF 在中国人中是一种少见的脊髓病病因,可在轻微创伤后急性发作。后路减压联合内固定融合术可获得较高的神经功能恢复,尽管脊髓前方仍有剩余的 OPLL 压迫。此外,该手术的术后并发症发生率较低。我们认为,对于术前脊髓严重受损的患者,或当全脊椎切除术伴有较高风险时,应选择一期后路减压联合内固定融合术。