Department of Health Management and Policy, College of Public Health, University of Iowa, Iowa City, IA 52242, USA.
Soc Sci Med. 2013 Feb;78:86-95. doi: 10.1016/j.socscimed.2012.11.038. Epub 2012 Dec 8.
Little is known about the importance of household wealth for child neurodevelopment very early in life including during infancy. Previous studies have focused on specific developmental domains instead of more holistic multi-domain measures of neurodevelopment and on economic effects for the "average" child instead of evaluating the heterogeneity in economic gradients by different levels of developmental ability. Furthermore, not much is known about whether economic gradients in early child neurodevelopment are country-specific or generalizable between populations. We evaluate wealth gradients in child neurodevelopment, an important predictor of future health and human capital, between ages 3 and 24 months in four South American countries. We also assess the heterogeneity in these gradients at different locations of the neurodevelopment distribution using quantile regression. Employing a unique dataset of 2032 children with neurodevelopment measures obtained by physicians in 2005-2006, we find a large positive wealth gradient in neurodevelopment in Brazil. The wealth gradient is larger for children at higher neurodevelopment rankings, suggesting that wealth is associated with child development inequalities in the form of a wider gap between low and high achievers on neurodevelopment in Brazil. This result highlights the need to target poverty in Brazil as a key factor in health and human capital disparities earlier in life rather than later as early developmental deficits will be carried forward and possibly multiplied later in life. More importantly, small or insignificant wealth gradients are generally found in the other countries. These results suggest that wealth gradients in child neurodevelopment are country-specific and vary with population demographic, health, and socioeconomic characteristics. Therefore, findings from previous studies based on specific populations may not be generalizable to other countries. Furthermore, wealth gradients in child neurodevelopment appear to be dynamic rather than fixed and sensitive to population characteristics that modify their intensity.
关于家庭财富对儿童神经发育的重要性,尤其是在生命早期(包括婴儿期)的影响,人们知之甚少。之前的研究主要集中在特定的发育领域,而不是更全面的多领域神经发育评估,以及针对“普通”儿童的经济影响,而不是评估不同发育能力水平的经济梯度的异质性。此外,人们对早期儿童神经发育的经济梯度是否具有国家特异性或在不同人群之间是否具有可推广性知之甚少。我们评估了四个南美国家在 3 至 24 个月大的儿童神经发育方面的财富梯度,神经发育是未来健康和人力资本的重要预测指标。我们还使用分位数回归评估了这些梯度在神经发育分布不同位置的异质性。利用 2005-2006 年医生对 2032 名儿童进行的神经发育测量的独特数据集,我们发现巴西的神经发育存在很大的正财富梯度。在神经发育排名较高的儿童中,财富梯度更大,这表明财富与儿童发展不平等有关,表现为在巴西,低成就者和高成就者之间的神经发育差距更大。这一结果强调了需要将巴西的贫困作为生命早期健康和人力资本差异的关键因素,而不是像以前那样在生命后期进行干预,因为早期发育缺陷将在以后的生活中持续存在并可能加剧。更重要的是,在其他国家通常发现财富梯度较小或不显著。这些结果表明,儿童神经发育的财富梯度具有国家特异性,并因人口人口统计学、健康和社会经济特征而有所不同。因此,基于特定人群的先前研究的结果可能不适用于其他国家。此外,儿童神经发育的财富梯度似乎是动态的,而不是固定的,并且对改变其强度的人口特征敏感。