Department of Urology, University of Wisconsin School of Medicine and Public Health, Madison, WI 53705, USA.
Urology. 2013 Mar;81(3):498-502. doi: 10.1016/j.urology.2012.10.021. Epub 2013 Jan 4.
To evaluate the outcomes of urgent ureteral stent placement under local anesthesia (LA) with those placed under general anesthesia (GA) for obstructing stones.
After institutional review board approval, ureteral stents placed from January 2007 to July 2011 at our institution were reviewed. Only primary stent placement for obstructing renal or ureteral calculi was included in the present analysis. Data were evaluated for 2 groups: GA and LA. The primary outcomes were demographics, interval from presentation to stent insertion, interval from stent insertion to stone removal, success and complication rates, and secondary outcomes were costs per encounter.
A total of 119 primary stent insertion procedures in 110 unique patients were assessed; 73 (GA) and 46 (LA). No differences were found in the mean age or sex between the 2 groups. Both GA and LA groups were stented within 12 hours of presentation, at 58% and 54%, respectively (P = .69); and the interval from stent insertion to stone removal was similar in both groups (mean 33 days and 35 days in the GA and LA groups, respectively, P = .79). No significant differences were found in the failure to place the stent between the GA and LA groups (1.3% vs 8.7%, respectively, P = .07). No complications related to stent placement occurred in either group. The average cost per encounter was nearly 4 times greater in the GA group.
Urgent ureteral stent placement for obstructing stones can be safely and effectively performed under LA in the office. Although avoiding GA and reducing costs, this approach did not prolong the interval to definitive stone management.
评估局部麻醉(LA)下与全身麻醉(GA)下紧急输尿管支架置入术治疗梗阻性结石的结果。
经机构审查委员会批准,回顾了 2007 年 1 月至 2011 年 7 月在我院进行的输尿管支架置入术。本分析仅包括原发性支架置入治疗肾或输尿管结石梗阻。对 GA 组和 LA 组的数据进行了评估。主要结局为人口统计学资料、从就诊到支架置入的时间间隔、从支架置入到结石取出的时间间隔、成功率和并发症发生率,次要结局为每次就诊的费用。
共评估了 110 例患者的 119 次原发性支架置入术;73 例(GA)和 46 例(LA)。两组间平均年龄和性别无差异。两组均在就诊后 12 小时内进行支架置入,分别为 58%和 54%(P=0.69);两组支架置入到结石取出的时间间隔相似(GA 组和 LA 组的平均时间分别为 33 天和 35 天,P=0.79)。GA 组和 LA 组均未出现支架置入失败(分别为 1.3%和 8.7%,P=0.07)。两组均未发生与支架置入相关的并发症。GA 组每次就诊的平均费用几乎是 LA 组的 4 倍。
在办公室中,LA 下可安全有效地进行梗阻性结石的紧急输尿管支架置入术。尽管避免了 GA 并降低了成本,但这种方法并未延长明确结石管理的时间间隔。