Centre for Conservation Ecology and Environmental Sciences, School of Applied Sciences, Bournemouth University, Fern Barrow, Poole, Dorset, UK.
PLoS One. 2013;8(1):e53200. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0053200. Epub 2013 Jan 16.
Public perception is a key factor influencing current conservation policy. Therefore, it is important to determine the influence of the public, end-users and scientists on the prioritisation of conservation issues and the direct implications for policy makers. Here, we assessed public attitudes and the perception of conservation managers to five non-native species in the UK, with these supplemented by those of an ecosystem user, freshwater anglers. We found that threat perception was not influenced by the volume of scientific research or by the actual threats posed by the specific non-native species. Media interest also reflected public perception and vice versa. Anglers were most concerned with perceived threats to their recreational activities but their concerns did not correspond to the greatest demonstrated ecological threat. The perception of conservation managers was an amalgamation of public and angler opinions but was mismatched to quantified ecological risks of the species. As this suggests that invasive species management in the UK is vulnerable to a knowledge gap, researchers must consider the intrinsic characteristics of their study species to determine whether raising public perception will be effective. The case study of the topmouth gudgeon Pseudorasbora parva reveals that media pressure and political debate has greater capacity to ignite policy changes and impact studies on non-native species than scientific evidence alone.
公众认知是影响当前保护政策的关键因素。因此,确定公众、最终用户和科学家对保护问题的优先级的影响,以及对政策制定者的直接影响,非常重要。在这里,我们评估了公众对英国五种非本地物种的态度和保护管理者的看法,并补充了生态系统使用者——淡水垂钓者的看法。我们发现,威胁感知不受科学研究数量或特定非本地物种实际构成的威胁的影响。媒体的关注也反映了公众的看法,反之亦然。垂钓者最关心的是他们娱乐活动面临的感知威胁,但他们的担忧与生态方面的最大威胁并不相符。保护管理者的看法是公众和垂钓者意见的混合,但与物种的量化生态风险不匹配。鉴于这表明英国的入侵物种管理容易受到知识差距的影响,研究人员必须考虑其研究物种的内在特征,以确定提高公众认知是否有效。基于圆口铜鱼的案例研究表明,与单纯的科学证据相比,媒体压力和政治辩论更有能力引发政策变化和对非本地物种的研究。