Brain and Cognitive Sciences, University of Rochester, Box 270268, Meliora Hall, Rochester, NY 14627, USA.
Anim Cogn. 2013 Sep;16(5):803-17. doi: 10.1007/s10071-013-0614-2. Epub 2013 Feb 22.
Some researchers have recently argued that humans may be unusual among primates in preferring to use landmark information when reasoning about some kinds of spatial problems. Some have explained this phenomenon by positing that our species' tendency to prefer landmarks stems from a human-unique trait: language. Here, we test this hypothesis-that preferring to use landmarks to solve such tasks is related to language ability-by exploring landmark use in a spatial task in one non-human primate, the brown capuchin monkey (Cebus apella). We presented our subjects with the rotational displacement task, in which subjects attempt to relocate a reward hidden within an array of hiding locations which are subsequently rotated to a new position. Over several experiments, we varied the availability and the salience of a landmark cue within the array. Specifically, we varied (1) visual access to the array during rotation, (2) the type of landmark, (3) the consistency of the landmark qualities, and (4) the amount of exposure to the landmark. Across Experiments 1 through 4, capuchins did not successfully use landmarks cues, suggesting that non-linguistic primates may not spontaneously use landmarks to solve some spatial problems, as in this case of a small-scale dynamic spatial task. Importantly, we also observed that capuchins demonstrated some capacity to learn to use landmarks in Experiment 4, suggesting that non-linguistic creatures may be able to use some landmarks cues in similar spatial tasks with extensive training.
一些研究人员最近提出,在推理某些类型的空间问题时,人类可能与灵长类动物不同,更倾向于使用地标信息。一些人通过假设我们物种更喜欢地标这一独特特征来解释这一现象:语言。在这里,我们通过探索一种非人类灵长类动物——棕色卷尾猴(Cebus apella)在空间任务中的地标使用情况来检验这一假设——即更喜欢使用地标来解决此类任务与语言能力有关。我们向研究对象展示了旋转位移任务,在该任务中,研究对象试图在隐藏在一系列隐藏位置中的奖励物重新定位,而这些隐藏位置随后会旋转到一个新位置。在几项实验中,我们改变了地标线索在数组中的可用性和显著性。具体来说,我们改变了:(1) 旋转过程中对数组的视觉访问;(2) 地标类型;(3) 地标质量的一致性;(4) 地标暴露量。在实验 1 到 4 中,卷尾猴并没有成功地使用地标线索,这表明非语言灵长类动物可能不会自发地使用地标来解决某些空间问题,就像在这种小规模的动态空间任务中一样。重要的是,我们还观察到,卷尾猴在实验 4 中表现出了一些学习使用地标线索的能力,这表明非语言生物可能能够在类似的空间任务中使用一些地标线索,只要经过充分的训练。