Møller Thea P, Madsen Marlene D, Fuhrmann Lone, Østergaard Doris
Danish Institute for Medical Simulation, of Anaesthesiology and Intensive Care, Herlev Hospital, Capital Region of Denmark, Herlev, Denmark.
Eur J Anaesthesiol. 2013 May;30(5):229-42. doi: 10.1097/EJA.0b013e32835d8520.
Current research has identified numerous safety risks related to patient handovers including postoperative handovers. During the postoperative handover and the recovery period, the patient is at risk of potential complications of surgery or anaesthesia. Furthermore, patients are subject to a downscale in monitoring and observation, which makes them vulnerable to incidents and errors.
To describe the characteristics and potential hazards to quality and patient safety during postoperative handover. To identify concrete recommendations for improvement in this process.
A systematic review of the literature.
Comprehensive search of electronic databases (Medline, Embase, Cochrane Library) in March 2012. Additional studies were obtained from bibliographies of retrieved reports.
Studies analysing the characteristics of the postoperative handover and interventional studies with the aim of improving postoperative handover. Only original research was included.
We identified 23 studies including descriptive and interventional studies. Postoperative handovers are described as a complex work process challenged by interruptions, time pressure and a lack of supporting framework. Interventional studies introduced standardised handover tools in combination with environmental changes, resulting in better flow of information in four out of five, better teamwork in two and less technical errors in two out of three studies.
Postoperative handover is a complex and dynamic situation. It is very important to analyse the challenges in the local setting and that solutions are customised to fit the specific context in which the postoperative handovers takes place. It is also important to acknowledge the role of non-technical skills in the work process with respect to patient safety. Implementation of new handover strategies must be considered carefully. To optimise the motivation for change among staff, the importance of improvement in postoperative handover in all settings must be outlined in future studies with more patient-specific outcomes.
当前研究已确定了与患者交接(包括术后交接)相关的众多安全风险。在术后交接和恢复期间,患者面临手术或麻醉潜在并发症的风险。此外,患者受到的监测和观察力度降低,这使他们容易遭遇事故和差错。
描述术后交接期间的特征以及对质量和患者安全的潜在危害。确定在此过程中改进的具体建议。
对文献进行系统综述。
2012年3月对电子数据库(Medline、Embase、Cochrane图书馆)进行全面检索。从检索报告的参考文献中获取其他研究。
分析术后交接特征的研究以及旨在改善术后交接的干预性研究。仅纳入原创研究。
我们确定了23项研究,包括描述性研究和干预性研究。术后交接被描述为一个复杂的工作流程,受到中断、时间压力和缺乏支持框架的挑战。干预性研究引入了标准化交接工具并结合环境变化,在五项研究中有四项信息流通得到改善,两项研究中团队协作得到改善,三项研究中有两项技术差错减少。
术后交接是一个复杂且动态的情况。分析当地环境中的挑战并针对术后交接发生的具体背景定制解决方案非常重要。认识到非技术技能在关乎患者安全的工作流程中的作用也很重要。必须谨慎考虑新交接策略的实施。为了优化员工对变革的积极性,未来研究必须概述在所有环境中改善术后交接的重要性,并得出更多针对患者的结果。