Department of Economics and Business, Barcelona Graduate School of Economics, Universitat Pompeu Fabra, 08005 Barcelona, Spain.
Ecology. 2013 Jan;94(1):241-9. doi: 10.1890/11-1730.1.
Correspondence analysis, when used to understand relationships in a table of counts (for example, abundance data in ecology), has been criticized as being too sensitive to objects (for example, species) that occur with very low frequency or in very few samples. Here I show that this criticism is generally unfounded. This is demonstrated in several data sets by calculating the actual contributions of rare objects to the results of correspondence analysis and canonical correspondence analysis, both to the determination of the ordination axes and to the chi-square distance. It is a fact that rare objects are often positioned as outliers in correspondence analysis ordinations, which gives the impression that they are highly influential, but their low weight offsets their distant positions and reduces their effect on the results. An alternative scaling of the correspondence analysis solution, the contribution biplot, is proposed as a way of displaying the results in order to avoid the problem of outlying and low contributing rare objects. In this new scaling of the biplot (or triplot in canonical correspondence analysis), species points have coordinates that are directly related to their contributions to the solution.
对应分析用于理解计数表(例如生态学中的丰度数据)中的关系,但它被批评为对出现频率非常低或在非常少的样本中出现的对象(例如物种)过于敏感。我在这里表明,这种批评通常是没有根据的。通过计算稀有对象对对应分析和典范对应分析结果的实际贡献,证明了这一点,包括对定序轴和卡方距离的贡献。事实上,稀有对象在对应分析排序中经常被定位为离群点,这给人一种它们具有高度影响力的印象,但它们的低权重抵消了它们的远距离位置,并降低了它们对结果的影响。提出了一种对应分析解的替代缩放方法,即贡献生物图,作为显示结果的一种方式,以避免离群和低贡献稀有对象的问题。在这种新的生物图(或典范对应分析中的三生物图)缩放中,物种点的坐标与其对解的贡献直接相关。