Department of Psychology, University of Florida, Gainesville, FL, USA.
Nat Sci Sleep. 2010 Mar 30;2:23-37. Print 2010.
The purpose of the present paper is to review and summarize the research supporting nonpharmacologic treatment options for insomnia. The different treatment approaches are described followed by a review of both original research articles and meta-analyses. Meta-analytic reviews suggest that common nonpharmacologic approaches exert, on average, medium to large effect sizes on SOL, WASO, NWAK, SQR, and SE while smaller effects are seen for TST. Stimulus control therapy, relaxation training, and CBT-I are considered standard treatments for insomnia by the American Academy of Sleep Medicine (AASM). Sleep restriction, multicomponent therapy without cognitive therapy, paradoxical intention, and biofeedback approaches have received some levels of support by the AASM. Sleep hygiene, imagery training, and cognitive therapy did not receive recommendation levels as single (standalone) therapies by the AASM due to lack of empirical evidence. Less common approaches have been introduced (Internet-based interventions, bright light treatment, biofeedback, mindfulness, acupuncture, and intensive sleep retraining) but require further research. Brief and group treatments have been shown to be as efficacious as longer and individually-administered treatments. Considerations are presented for special populations, including older adults, children and teens, individuals from diverse cultural backgrounds, insomnia comorbid with other disorders, and individuals who are taking hypnotics.
本文旨在回顾和总结支持非药物治疗失眠症的研究。描述了不同的治疗方法,随后对原始研究文章和荟萃分析进行了回顾。荟萃分析综述表明,常见的非药物方法对 SOL、WASO、NWAK、SQR 和 SE 的平均影响大小为中等到大,而 TST 的影响较小。刺激控制疗法、放松训练和 CBT-I 被美国睡眠医学学会 (AASM) 认为是失眠的标准治疗方法。睡眠限制、没有认知疗法的多成分疗法、矛盾意向和生物反馈疗法得到了 AASM 的一定程度的支持。由于缺乏经验证据,睡眠卫生、意象训练和认知疗法没有被 AASM 推荐为单一(独立)疗法。已经引入了一些不太常见的方法(基于互联网的干预、亮光治疗、生物反馈、正念、针灸和强化睡眠再训练),但需要进一步研究。简短和小组治疗已被证明与较长和单独进行的治疗同样有效。本文还考虑了特殊人群,包括老年人、儿童和青少年、来自不同文化背景的个体、失眠合并其他疾病的个体以及正在服用催眠药的个体。