Ide Mark, Papapanou Panos N
Periodontology, King's College London Dental Institute, London, UK.
J Clin Periodontol. 2013 Apr;40 Suppl 14:S181-94. doi: 10.1111/jcpe.12063.
There is still debate regarding potential relationships between maternal periodontitis during pregnancy and adverse pregnancy outcomes. The aim of this systematic review was to synthesize the available epidemiological evidence on this association.
Combined electronic and hand search of MEDLINE, EMBASE, WEB OF SCIENCE and Cochrane Central Register databases.
Original publications reporting data from cross-sectional, case-control or prospective cohort epidemiological studies on the association between periodontal status and preterm birth, low birthweight (LBW) or pre-eclampsia. The search was not limited to publications in English. All selected studies provided data based on professional assessments of periodontal status, and outcome variables, including preterm birth (<37 weeks gestation), LBW (<2500 g), gestational age, small for gestational age, birthweight, pregnancy loss or miscarriage, or pre-eclampsia.
Pregnant women with or without periodontal disease, and with or without adverse pregnancy outcomes, assessed either during pregnancy or postpartum. No intervention studies were included. Study appraisal and synthesis methods - Publications were assessed based on predefined screening criteria including type of periodontal assessment, consistency in the timing of the periodontal assessment with respect to gestational age, examiner masking and consideration of additional exposures and confounders.
Maternal periodontitis is modestly but significantly associated with LBW and preterm birth, but the use of a categorical or a continuous exposure definition of periodontitis appears to impact the findings: Although significant associations emerge from case-control and cross-sectional studies using periodontitis "case definitions," these were substantially attenuated in studies assessing periodontitis as a continuous variable. Data from prospective studies followed a similar pattern, but associations were generally weaker. Maternal periodontitis was significantly associated with pre-eclampsia.
There is a high degree of variability in study populations, recruitment and assessment, as well as differences in how data are recorded and handled. As a result, studies included in meta-analyses show a high degree of heterogeneity.
Maternal periodontitis is modestly but independently associated with adverse pregnancy outcomes, but the findings are impacted by periodontitis case definitions. It is suggested that future studies employ both continuous and categorical assessments of periodontal status. Further use of the composite outcome preterm LBW is not encouraged.
关于孕期母体牙周炎与不良妊娠结局之间的潜在关系仍存在争议。本系统评价的目的是综合有关这种关联的现有流行病学证据。
对MEDLINE、EMBASE、科学网和考克兰中央对照试验注册库数据库进行电子检索与手工检索相结合。
原始出版物报告来自横断面、病例对照或前瞻性队列流行病学研究的数据,这些研究涉及牙周状况与早产、低出生体重(LBW)或先兆子痫之间的关联。检索不限于英文出版物。所有选定研究均基于对牙周状况的专业评估以及结局变量提供数据,结局变量包括早产(妊娠<37周)、低出生体重(<2500克)、孕周、小于胎龄儿、出生体重、妊娠丢失或流产,或先兆子痫。
在孕期或产后评估的患有或未患有牙周疾病、有或无不良妊娠结局的孕妇。未纳入干预性研究。研究评估与综合方法——根据预定义的筛选标准对出版物进行评估,这些标准包括牙周评估类型、牙周评估时间与孕周的一致性、检查者设盲以及对其他暴露因素和混杂因素的考虑。
母体牙周炎与低出生体重和早产存在适度但显著的关联,但牙周炎的分类或连续暴露定义的使用似乎会影响研究结果:尽管使用牙周炎“病例定义”的病例对照研究和横断面研究得出了显著关联,但在将牙周炎作为连续变量进行评估的研究中,这些关联大幅减弱。前瞻性研究的数据呈现类似模式,但关联通常较弱。母体牙周炎与先兆子痫显著相关。
研究人群、招募和评估存在高度变异性,以及数据记录和处理方式存在差异。因此,纳入荟萃分析的研究显示出高度异质性。
母体牙周炎与不良妊娠结局存在适度但独立的关联,但研究结果受牙周炎病例定义的影响。建议未来研究同时采用牙周状况的连续和分类评估。不鼓励进一步使用早产低出生体重这一综合结局。