Thiebaud Robert S, Loenneke Jeremy P, Fahs Christopher A, Rossow Lindy M, Kim Daeyeol, Abe Takashi, Anderson Mark A, Young Kaelin C, Bemben Debra A, Bemben Michael G
Department of Health and Exercise Science, University of Oklahoma, Norman, OK 73019, USA.
Clin Physiol Funct Imaging. 2013 Sep;33(5):344-52. doi: 10.1111/cpf.12033. Epub 2013 Apr 3.
Elastic band (EB) training is a common form of resistance training used by the elderly, individuals with joint problems or those recovering from injury. EB training performed at low intensities by these populations may have little effect on muscle hypertrophy. However, when combined with blood flow restriction (BFR), low-intensity EB resistance training may result in muscle hypertrophy.
Postmenopausal women (61 ± 5 years) were assigned to a moderate-to-high-intensity EB group (MH, n = 8) or a low-intensity EB group combined with BFR (LI-BFR, n = 6). Each group performed seated chest press, seated row and seated shoulder press with EB three times a week for eight weeks. EB colours progressed in each group by having participants maintain a rating of 7-9 on the OMNI Resistance for active muscle (OMNI-RES AM) scale (0-10) throughout training. In the LI-BFR group, BFR pressure progressed during the first 4 weeks of training (80-120 mmHg), after which EB colours were progressed.
1-repetition maximum increased for chest press (P = 0.01), shoulder press (P = 0.02) and seated row (P = 0.01), but no differences were found between groups. Only pectoralis major muscle thickness in the upper body increased (P = 0.04). A trend was found for an increase in total bone-free lean body mass (P = 0.055).
The main findings of this study were that moderate-to-high-intensity EB training and low-intensity EB training with BFR resulted in similar increases in strength, total bone-free lean body mass and muscle thickness.
弹力带(EB)训练是老年人、关节有问题的个体或受伤后正在恢复的人常用的一种抗阻训练形式。这些人群进行低强度的EB训练可能对肌肉肥大影响甚微。然而,当与血流限制(BFR)相结合时,低强度EB抗阻训练可能会导致肌肉肥大。
将绝经后女性(61±5岁)分为中高强度EB组(MH,n = 8)或低强度EB联合BFR组(LI-BFR,n = 6)。每组每周进行3次弹力带坐姿推胸、坐姿划船和坐姿推举训练,持续8周。在整个训练过程中,通过让参与者在主动肌肉的OMNI抗阻量表(OMNI-RES AM)(0-10)上保持7-9的评分,使每组弹力带颜色逐渐增加。在LI-BFR组中,BFR压力在训练的前4周(80-120 mmHg)逐渐增加,之后弹力带颜色再逐渐增加。
卧推(P = 0.01)、肩推(P = 0.02)和坐姿划船(P = 0.01)的1次最大重复量增加,但两组之间未发现差异。仅上身的胸大肌厚度增加(P = 0.04)。发现无脂肪瘦体重总量有增加的趋势(P = 0.055)。
本研究的主要发现是,中高强度EB训练和低强度EB联合BFR训练在力量、无脂肪瘦体重总量和肌肉厚度增加方面效果相似。