The University of Hong Kong, School of Chinese Medicine, Hong Kong 852, China.
Asian J Androl. 2013 Jul;15(4):471-82. doi: 10.1038/aja.2012.173. Epub 2013 Jun 3.
Chinese herbal medicine is commonly used as a treatment for benign prostatic hyperplasia (BPH), but its efficacy and safety remain to be examined. To compare the efficacy and adverse events of Chinese herbal medicine alone or used adjuvantly with Western medications for BPH. Two independent reviewers searched the major electronic databases for randomized controlled trials comparing Chinese herbal medicine, either in single or adjuvant use with Western medication, with placebo or Western medication. Relevant journals and grey literature were also hand-searched. The outcome measures included changes in urological symptoms, urodynamic measures, prostate volume and adverse events. The frequency of commonly used herbs was also identified. Out of 13 922 identified citations of publications, 31 studies were included. Eleven studies with a Jadad score ≥ 3 were selected for meta-analysis. Chinese herbal medicine was superior to Western medication in improving quality of life and reducing prostate volume. The frequency of adverse events in Chinese herbal medicine was similar to that of placebo and less than that of Western medication. The evidence is too weak to support the efficacy of Chinese herbal medicine for BPH due to the poor methodological quality and small number of trials included. The commonly used herbs identified here should provide insights for future clinical practice and research. Larger randomized controlled trials of better quality are needed to truly evaluate the efficacy of Chinese herbal medicine.
中草药常用于治疗良性前列腺增生症(BPH),但其疗效和安全性仍需进一步研究。为比较单独使用中草药或与西药联合使用治疗 BPH 的疗效和不良反应。两位独立评审员检索了主要电子数据库,以比较单独使用中草药或与西药联合使用与安慰剂或西药治疗 BPH 的随机对照试验。还对相关期刊和灰色文献进行了手工检索。主要观察指标包括泌尿科症状、尿动力学指标、前列腺体积和不良反应的变化。还确定了常用草药的使用频率。在 13922 篇出版物的引文记录中,有 31 项研究被纳入。对 11 项 Jadad 评分≥3 的研究进行了荟萃分析。中草药在改善生活质量和缩小前列腺体积方面优于西药。中草药组不良反应的发生频率与安慰剂组相似,且低于西药组。由于纳入的试验数量较少且方法学质量较差,证据太弱,无法支持中草药治疗 BPH 的疗效。这里确定的常用草药应能为未来的临床实践和研究提供思路。需要开展更多高质量的随机对照试验,以真正评估中草药的疗效。