Macintyre Norma J, Lineker Sydney C, Hallett Christina, Tumber Jake, Fernando Nalin, Hul Magdalena
School of Rehabilitation Science, McMaster University, Hamilton.
Physiother Can. 2012 Summer;64(3):262-70. doi: 10.3138/ptc.2010-44.
This study examined whether physiotherapy students in a problem-based learning (PBL) curriculum intend to implement best practices for management of clients with rheumatoid arthritis (RA).
Physiotherapy students (n=49) completed a subsection of the ACREU Primary Care Survey to evaluate the concordance between intended behaviours and Canadian best practices for early- and late-stage RA, before and after completing the relevant PBL content. Changes in scores were assessed using McNemar's test for dependent proportions.
Most students indicated that they would recommend treatments or referrals for physiotherapy/exercise, education, and occupational therapy or joint protection pre- and post-PBL (>83% and >95%, respectively). Post-PBL, more students recommended referral to a rheumatologist and disease-modifying anti-rheumatic drugs (DMARDs) for both early and late RA; however, the increase was significant only for early RA (p=0.013 and 0.031 for referral to rheumatologist and DMARDs, respectively). More students recommended psychosocial support at both stages of RA post-PBL (early RA: p<0.001; late RA: p=0.031). Although more students recommended DMARDs post-PBL, only 8 students in total made this recommendation (16%), and fewer students considered use of non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs. Most students (94%) did not recommend referral to a surgeon for early or late RA.
Intended behaviour of physiotherapy students was more consistent with Canadian best practice guidelines for managing clients with early- and late-stage RA following the PBL curriculum. Further study is required to determine whether the students were less aware of best practices related to pharmacologic interventions and timely referral to appropriate specialists, or whether they considered these issues to be outside their scope of practice.
本研究调查了采用基于问题的学习(PBL)课程的物理治疗专业学生是否打算对类风湿关节炎(RA)患者实施最佳管理实践。
物理治疗专业学生(n = 49)在完成相关PBL内容之前和之后,完成了ACREU初级保健调查的一个子部分,以评估预期行为与加拿大RA早期和晚期最佳实践之间的一致性。使用McNemar相依比例检验评估分数变化。
大多数学生表示,在PBL前后,他们会推荐物理治疗/运动、教育、职业治疗或关节保护的治疗或转诊(分别>83%和>95%)。PBL后,更多学生推荐早期和晚期RA患者转诊至风湿病学家并使用改善病情抗风湿药(DMARDs);然而,仅早期RA的增加具有统计学意义(转诊至风湿病学家和DMARDs的p值分别为0.013和0.031)。PBL后,更多学生在RA的两个阶段都推荐心理社会支持(早期RA:p<0.001;晚期RA:p = 0.031)。尽管PBL后更多学生推荐使用DMARDs,但总共只有8名学生(16%)提出此建议,且更少学生考虑使用非甾体抗炎药。大多数学生(94%)不推荐早期或晚期RA患者转诊至外科医生。
物理治疗专业学生的预期行为在PBL课程后与加拿大RA早期和晚期患者管理的最佳实践指南更为一致。需要进一步研究以确定学生是较少了解与药物干预和及时转诊至适当专科医生相关的最佳实践,还是他们认为这些问题超出了其执业范围。