Kumar S Krishna, Khare P, Jaryal A K, Talwar A
Department of Physiology, All India Institute of Medical Sciences, New Delhi.
Indian J Physiol Pharmacol. 2012 Jul-Sep;56(3):279-83.
Maximal oxygen uptake (VO2max) during a graded maximal exercise test is the objective method to assess cardiorespiratory fitness. Maximal oxygen uptake testing is limited to only a few laboratories as it requires trained personnel and strenuous effort by the subject. At the population level, submaximal tests have been developed to derive VO2max indirectly based on heart rate based nomograms or it can be calculated using anthropometric measures. These heart rate based predicted standards have been developed for western population and are used routinely to predict VO2max in Indian population. In the present study VO2max was directly measured by maximal exercise test using a bicycle ergometer and was compared with VO2max derived by recovery heart rate in Queen's College step test (QCST) (PVO2max I) and with VO2max derived from Wasserman equation based on anthropometric parameters and age (PVO2max II) in a well defined age group of healthy male adults from New Delhi. The values of directly measured VO2max showed no significant correlation either with the estimated VO2max with QCST or with VO2max predicted by Wasserman equation. Bland and Altman method of approach for limit of agreement between VO2max and PVO2max I or PVO2max II revealed that the limits of agreement between directly measured VO2max and PVO2max I or PVO2max II was large indicating inapplicability of prediction equations of western population in the population under study. Thus it is evident that there is an urgent need to develop nomogram for Indian population, may be even for different ethnic sub-population in the country.
在分级最大运动试验中,最大摄氧量(VO2max)是评估心肺适能的客观方法。最大摄氧量测试仅限于少数实验室,因为它需要训练有素的人员以及受试者付出巨大努力。在人群层面,已开发出次最大运动试验,以基于心率的列线图间接推算VO2max,或者可以使用人体测量指标进行计算。这些基于心率的预测标准是针对西方人群制定的,并常规用于预测印度人群的VO2max。在本研究中,通过使用自行车测力计的最大运动试验直接测量VO2max,并将其与在女王学院台阶试验(QCST)中通过恢复心率推算出的VO2max(PVO2max I)以及在来自新德里的健康成年男性明确年龄组中基于人体测量参数和年龄通过 Wasserman 方程推算出的VO2max(PVO2max II)进行比较。直接测量的VO2max值与通过QCST估算的VO2max或与Wasserman方程预测的VO2max均无显著相关性。Bland和Altman方法用于评估VO2max与PVO2max I或PVO2max II之间的一致性界限,结果显示直接测量的VO2max与PVO2max I或PVO2max II之间的一致性界限很大,表明西方人群的预测方程不适用于所研究的人群。因此,显然迫切需要为印度人群,甚至可能为该国不同的种族亚人群开发列线图。