Morris J N, Clayton D G, Everitt M G, Semmence A M, Burgess E H
Department of Public Health and Policy, London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine.
Br Heart J. 1990 Jun;63(6):325-34. doi: 10.1136/hrt.63.6.325.
Nine thousand three hundred and seventy six male civil servants, aged 45-64 at entry, with no clinical history of coronary heart disease, were followed for a mean period of 9 years and 4 months during which 474 experienced a coronary attack. The 9% of men who reported that they often participated in vigorous sports or did considerable amounts of cycling or rated the pace of their regular walking as fast (over 4 mph, 6.4 km/h) experienced less than half the non-fatal and fatal coronary heart disease of the other men. In addition, entrants aged 55-64 who reported the next lower degree of this vigorous aerobic exercise had rates less than two thirds of the remainder; entrants of 45-54 did not show such an effect. When these forms of exercise were not vigorous they were no protection against the disease, nor were other forms of exercise or high totals of physical activity per se. A history of vigorous sports in the past was not protective. Indications in these men are of protection by specific exercise: vigorous, aerobic, with a threshold of intensity for benefit and "dose response" above this threshold, exercise that has to be habitual, and continuing, which suggests that protection is against the acute phases of the disease. Those men who took vigorous aerobic exercise were demonstrably a favourably "selected" group; they suffered less of the disease, however, whether at low risk or high by the several risk factors that were studied. Men with exercise-related reduction in coronary heart disease also had lower death rates from the total of other causes, and so lower total death rates than the rest of the men.
9376名男性公务员,入职时年龄在45至64岁之间,无冠心病临床病史,平均随访9年零4个月,在此期间有474人发生了冠心病发作。报告经常参加剧烈运动、大量骑自行车或认为自己日常步行速度快(超过每小时4英里,即6.4公里/小时)的男性中,非致命性和致命性冠心病的发病率不到其他男性的一半。此外,55至64岁的入职者报告进行次低强度这种剧烈有氧运动时,发病率不到其余人员的三分之二;45至54岁的入职者未显示出这种效果。当这些运动形式强度不大时,它们对疾病没有预防作用,其他运动形式或总体高运动量本身也没有预防作用。过去有剧烈运动史并无预防作用。这些男性的情况表明,特定运动具有预防作用:剧烈、有氧、有受益的强度阈值且高于此阈值有“剂量反应”,必须是习惯性且持续的运动,这表明预防作用针对的是疾病的急性期。那些进行剧烈有氧运动的男性显然是经过“有利选择”的群体;无论根据所研究的几个风险因素处于低风险还是高风险,他们患该病的几率都较低。与运动相关的冠心病发病率降低的男性因其他原因导致的死亡率也较低,因此总死亡率低于其他男性。