Menon Sonia
University of Ghent, Ghent, Belgium.
Glob J Health Sci. 2013 May 15;5(4):200-10. doi: 10.5539/gjhs.v5n4p200.
In sub Saharan Africa, the cocktail of many advanced HIV-infected susceptible hosts, poor TB treatment success rates, a lack of airborne infection control, limited drug-resistance testing (DST) have resulted in HIV-infected individuals being disproportionately represented in Multi drug resistant Tuberculosis (MDR-TB) cases. The prevailing application of the WHO re-treatment protocol indiscriminately to all re-treatment cases sets the stage for an increase in mortality and MDR-TB nosocomial transmission.
A comprehensive search was performed of the Cochrane Infectious Diseases Group Specialized Register and Medline database including the bibliographies of the retrieved reference.
The TB diagnosis paradigm which for decades relied on smear sputum and culture is likely to change with the advent of the point-of-care diagnostic, Xpert MTB/RIF assay. Until the new DST infrastructure is available, along with clinical trials for both, current and new approaches to retreatment TB in areas heavily affected by HIV and TB, there are cost effective administrative, environmental, and protective measures that may be immediately instituted.
The severe lack of infection control practices in sub Saharan Africa may jeopardise the recent strides in MDR-TB management. Cost effective infection control measures must be immediately implemented, otherwise the development of further drug resistance may offset recent strides in MDR-TB management. Indiscriminate use of the WHO standardized retreatment protocol can lead to nosocomial transmission of MDR-TB by: -Precluding early diagnosis and prompt separation of patients who experienced treatment failure category and thereby more likely to have MDR-TB. -Leaving patients from the treatment failure category in health establishments on ineffective standard retreatment regimen until the DST results are known. -targeting only patients who have had prior TB therapy, new severely debilitated TB patients having primary unrecognized MDR-TB may continue spreading resistant organisms.
在撒哈拉以南非洲,众多晚期HIV感染易感宿主、结核病治疗成功率低、缺乏空气传播感染控制措施以及有限的耐药性检测等因素共同作用,导致HIV感染者在耐多药结核病(MDR-TB)病例中所占比例过高。世界卫生组织(WHO)的再治疗方案不加区分地应用于所有再治疗病例,为死亡率上升和MDR-TB医院内传播埋下了隐患。
对Cochrane传染病组专业注册库和Medline数据库进行全面检索,包括检索参考文献的书目。
几十年来依赖痰涂片和培养的结核病诊断模式可能会随着即时诊断Xpert MTB/RIF检测的出现而改变。在新的耐药性检测基础设施可用之前,以及针对受HIV和结核病严重影响地区的现有和新的结核病再治疗方法的临床试验开展之前,可以立即采取具有成本效益的行政、环境和防护措施。
撒哈拉以南非洲严重缺乏感染控制措施,可能会危及近期在MDR-TB管理方面取得的进展。必须立即实施具有成本效益的感染控制措施,否则进一步的耐药性发展可能会抵消近期在MDR-TB管理方面取得的进展。不加区分地使用WHO标准化再治疗方案可能导致MDR-TB在医院内传播,原因如下:- 排除对治疗失败类患者的早期诊断和及时隔离,这些患者更有可能患有MDR-TB。- 在卫生机构中,让治疗失败类患者接受无效的标准再治疗方案,直到获得耐药性检测结果。- 仅针对曾接受过结核病治疗的患者,新出现的严重衰弱且患有原发性未被识别的MDR-TB的患者可能会继续传播耐药菌。