Rocque Brandon G, Amancherla Kaushik, Lew Sean M, Lam Sandi
Department of Neurosurgery, University of Wisconsin, Madison, Wisconsin, USA.
J Neurosurg Pediatr. 2013 Aug;12(2):120-5. doi: 10.3171/2013.4.PEDS12605. Epub 2013 Jun 21.
Cranioplasty is routinely performed following decompressive craniectomy in both adult and pediatric populations. In adults, this procedure is associated with higher rates of complications than is elective cranial surgery. This study is a review of the literature describing risk factors for complications after cranioplasty surgery in pediatric patients. A systematic search of PubMed, Cochrane, and SCOPUS databases was undertaken. Articles were selected based on their titles and abstracts. Only studies that focused on a pediatric population were included; case reports were excluded. Studies in which the authors assessed bone flap storage method, timing of cranioplasty, material used (synthetic vs autogenous), skull defect size, and/or complication rates (bone resorption and surgical site infection) were selected for further analysis. Eleven studies that included a total of 441 cranioplasties performed in the pediatric population are included in this review. The findings are as follows: 1) Based on analysis of pooled data, using cryopreserved bone flaps during cranioplasty may lead to a higher rate of bone resorption and lower rate of infection than using bone flaps stored at room temperature. 2) In 3 of 4 articles describing the effect of time between craniectomy and cranioplasty on complication rate, the authors found no significant effect, while in 1 the authors found that the incidence of bone resorption was significantly lower in children who had undergone early cranioplasty. Pooling of data was not possible for this analysis. 3) There are insufficient data to assess the effect of cranioplasty material on complication rate when considering only cranioplasties performed to repair decompressive craniectomy defects. However, when considering cranioplasties performed for any indication, those in which freshly harvested autograft is used may have a lower rate of resorption than those in which stored autograft is used. 4) There is no appreciable effect of craniectomy defect size or patient age on complication rate. There is a paucity of articles describing outcomes and complications following cranioplasty in children and adolescents. However, based on the studies examined in this systematic review, there are reasons to suspect that method of flap preservation, timing of surgery, and material used may be significant. Larger prospective and retrospective studies are needed to shed more light on this important issue.
颅骨修补术在成人和儿童群体中,减压性颅骨切除术后通常都会进行。在成人中,该手术的并发症发生率高于择期颅骨手术。本研究是对描述小儿患者颅骨修补术后并发症危险因素的文献综述。对PubMed、Cochrane和SCOPUS数据库进行了系统检索。文章根据标题和摘要进行筛选。仅纳入关注儿童群体的研究;排除病例报告。选择作者评估骨瓣储存方法、颅骨修补术时机、使用材料(合成材料与自体材料)、颅骨缺损大小和/或并发症发生率(骨吸收和手术部位感染)的研究进行进一步分析。本综述纳入了11项研究,共包括在小儿群体中进行的441例颅骨修补术。研究结果如下:1)基于汇总数据分析,颅骨修补术中使用冷冻保存的骨瓣可能比使用室温保存的骨瓣导致更高的骨吸收率和更低的感染率。2)在4篇描述颅骨切除与颅骨修补术之间的时间间隔对并发症发生率影响的文章中,3篇文章的作者未发现显著影响,而1篇文章的作者发现早期进行颅骨修补术的儿童骨吸收发生率显著更低。此分析无法进行数据汇总。3)仅考虑为修复减压性颅骨切除术缺损而进行的颅骨修补术时,评估颅骨修补材料对并发症发生率影响的数据不足。然而,考虑因任何适应症进行的颅骨修补术时,使用新鲜采集的自体移植骨的手术骨吸收率可能低于使用储存自体移植骨的手术。4)颅骨切除缺损大小或患者年龄对并发症发生率没有明显影响。描述儿童和青少年颅骨修补术后结局和并发症的文章较少。然而,基于本系统综述中审查的研究,有理由怀疑骨瓣保存方法、手术时机和使用材料可能很重要。需要更大规模的前瞻性和回顾性研究来更清楚地阐明这个重要问题。