Krishnan Ajay, Dave Bharat R, Kambar Arun Kumar, Ram Himanshu
"STAVYA" Spine Hospital and Research Institute, Nr. Nagari Hospital, Mithakhali, Ellisbridge, Ahmedabad, 380006, Gujarat, India,
Eur Spine J. 2014 Jan;23(1):64-73. doi: 10.1007/s00586-013-2868-4. Epub 2013 Jun 24.
Retrospective analysis of 53 patients who underwent single stage simultaneous surgery for tandem spinal stenosis (TSS) at single centre.
To discuss the presentation of combined cervical and lumbar (tandem) stenosis and to evaluate the safety and efficacy of single-stage simultaneous surgery. Combined stenosis is an infrequent presentation with mixed presentation of upper motor neuron and lower motor neuron signs. Scarce literature on its presentation and management is available. There is a controversy in the surgical strategy of these patients. Staged surgeries are frequently recommended and only few single-stage surgeries reported.
All the patients were clinico-radiologically diagnosed TSS. Surgeries were performed in single stage by two teams. Results were evaluated with Nurick grade, modified Japanese Orthopedic Association score (mJOA), oswestry disability index (ODI), patient satisfaction index, mJOA recovery rate, blood loss and complication.
The mJOA cervical and ODI score improved from a mean 8.86 and 68.15 preoperatively to 13.00 and 30.11, respectively, at 12 months and to 14.52 and 24.03 at final follow-up. The average mJOA recovery rate was 48.23 ± 26.90 %. Patient satisfaction index was 2.13 ± 0.91 at final follow-up. Estimated blood loss of ≤400 ml and operating room time of <150 min showed improvement of scores and lessened the complications. In the age group below 60 years, the improvement was statistically significant in ODI (p = 0.02) and Nurick's grade (p = 0.03) with average improvement in mJOA score.
Short-lasting surgery, single anaesthesia, reduced morbidity and hospital stay as well as costs, an early return to function, high patient satisfaction rate with encouraging results justify single-stage surgery in TSS. Age, blood loss and duration of surgery decide the complication rate and outcome of surgery. Staged surgery is recommended in patients above the age of 60 years.
对在单一中心接受串联性椎管狭窄(TSS)一期同步手术的53例患者进行回顾性分析。
探讨合并颈椎和腰椎(串联性)狭窄的表现,并评估一期同步手术的安全性和有效性。合并狭窄是一种少见的情况,伴有上运动神经元和下运动神经元体征的混合表现。关于其表现和治疗的文献稀少。这些患者的手术策略存在争议。经常推荐分期手术,仅报道了少数一期手术。
所有患者均经临床放射学诊断为TSS。手术由两个团队一期完成。结果采用Nurick分级、改良日本骨科学会评分(mJOA)、奥斯威斯利功能障碍指数(ODI)、患者满意度指数、mJOA恢复率、失血量和并发症进行评估。
mJOA颈椎评分和ODI评分分别从术前的平均8.86和68.15改善至术后12个月时的13.00和30.11,最终随访时分别为14.52和24.03。平均mJOA恢复率为48.23±26.90%。最终随访时患者满意度指数为2.13±0.91。估计失血量≤400ml且手术时间<150分钟可使评分改善并减少并发症。在60岁以下年龄组,ODI(p = 0.02)和Nurick分级(p = 0.03)有统计学意义的改善,mJOA评分平均改善。
手术时间短、单次麻醉、发病率降低、住院时间和费用减少、功能恢复早、患者满意度高且结果令人鼓舞,证明TSS一期手术是合理的。年龄、失血量和手术时长决定了并发症发生率和手术结果。建议60岁以上患者采用分期手术。