Mental Health Sciences Unit, UCL, 67-73 Riding House Street 2nd Floor, Charles Bell House, London W1W 7EJ, UK.
Int Psychogeriatr. 2013 Nov;25(11):1849-58. doi: 10.1017/S1041610213001221. Epub 2013 Aug 7.
One in three adults, most of whom are living in a care home at the time, dies with dementia. Their end-of-life is often in hospital, where they may experience uncomfortable interventions without known benefit and die rapidly with uncontrolled pain and comfort needs. This study aimed to improve end-of-life care for people with dementia in a care home by increasing the number and implementation of advanced care wishes.
We recruited staff, residents with dementia, and their relatives from a 120-bed nursing home in London, UK. The intervention was a ten-session manualized, interactive staff training program. We compared advance care wishes documentation and implementation, place of death for residents who died, and themes from staff and family carers' after-death interviews pre- and post-intervention.
Post-intervention there were significant increases in documented advance care wishes arising from residents' and relatives' discussions with staff about end-of-life. These included do not resuscitate orders (16/22, 73% vs. 4/28, 14%; p < 0.001); and dying in the care homes as opposed to hospital (22/29, 76% vs. 14/30, 47%; p < 0.02). Bereaved relatives overall satisfaction increased from 7.5 (SD = 1.3) pre-intervention to 9.1 (SD = 2.4) post-intervention; t = 17.6, p = 0.06. Relatives reported increased consultation and satisfaction about decisions. Staff members were more confident about end-of-life planning and implementing advanced wishes.
This small non-randomized study is the first end-of-life care in dementia intervention to report an increase in family satisfaction with a reduction in hospital deaths. This is promising but requires further evaluation in diverse care homes.
三分之一的成年人,其中大多数在临终时住在养老院,患有痴呆症。他们的生命末期往往在医院,在那里他们可能会经历没有已知益处的不适干预,并在没有控制的疼痛和舒适需求的情况下迅速死亡。本研究旨在通过增加预先护理意愿的数量和实施来改善养老院中痴呆症患者的临终护理。
我们从英国伦敦的一家 120 床养老院招募了工作人员、患有痴呆症的居民及其家属。干预措施是一个十节的、有针对性的员工培训计划。我们比较了居民死亡时的预先护理意愿记录和实施情况、居民死亡地点,以及干预前后工作人员和家属在死亡后的访谈主题。
干预后,记录的预先护理意愿显著增加,这些意愿源于居民及其家属与工作人员就临终问题进行的讨论,包括不进行心肺复苏术的意愿(16/22,73%比 4/28,14%;p < 0.001);以及在养老院而不是医院死亡的意愿(22/29,76%比 14/30,47%;p < 0.02)。丧亲的家属总体满意度从干预前的 7.5(标准差 = 1.3)增加到干预后的 9.1(标准差 = 2.4);t = 17.6,p = 0.06。家属报告说,对决策的咨询和满意度有所提高。工作人员对临终规划和实施预先护理意愿更有信心。
这项小型非随机研究是第一个报告家庭满意度提高和医院死亡人数减少的痴呆症临终关怀干预研究。这是有希望的,但需要在不同的养老院进行进一步评估。